They havent drafted well since 2013. If they've done so well, why did everyone consider their prospect pool to be one of the league's worst every year since 2014?
Nobody wants their prospects. Shestyorkin and Saarela, thats about it. The 2014 draft was a disaster, and 2015 -- the best draft in 12 years -- is heading in that direction. Too early to assess 2016 but not one forward has star potential.
Again, they are a good team and rarely get chances to draft a star. You can rag on Buffalo all you want, but they have Eichel, Nylander and now Mittelstadt - all three have legitimate all-star potential.
You need stars to win Cups. They had a chance to draft two of them and went the safe route instead.
Mittelstadt and Kostin -- blows my mind how you pass up the draft's best power forward and 2nd/3rd best playmaker.
I will take it to my grave - they would still have drafted Andersson and Chytil even after trading down and adding more picks.
So you'd be looking at Chytil, Andersson, AND added the likes of Lipanov and Ikonen on top of that.
Because they haven't had a pick in the first round for 5 years. That should be pretty clear. They've hit some great guys in later rounds, but good luck in the 3rd and 4th is relative - good luck and/or good work is getting a few gems over a period of years in those rounds, not getting a solid NHLer every draft. That's what the first is for and they simply haven't been there.
They've done well with what they've had. You dismiss Shesty and Saarella like oh it's only two great picks. Yes, a fourth rounder and a third rounder, one of which is a top goalie in the second best league in the world and the other who looks like a solid NHL player. And they also have guys that the jury is still out on from recent years, as all teams do, plus their great successes in 12 and 13 - Buch, Duclair, Graves, Skjei, Nieves.
2014 was such a disaster that a team with no 1st round pick got a guy who is now one of the best goalie prospects on the planet. That's not a disaster, that's getting an excellent player with pretty crappy picks.
2015 wasn't great, but again, crappy picks and they got a great player in Saarela who they foolishly traded.
No-one from 2016 has star potential? Their first pick was 81 overall and they got a good deal in Day, that's not a disaster, that's what one would expect when you don't pick until the third round. Plus the jury is still out on some of the other picks that year.
You're confusing the picks they had with the job they did using them imo. I maintain that they've done well with what they had, they just hadn't set themselves up to get stars very well.
I can and will rag on a team that can barely get out of the basement. Winning is the point of the league, not collecting potentially good players and wasting their careers. Eichel is in contract talks already and what have they accomplished with him on his ELC? Less than nothing. Too many people fetishize potential without thinking about the fact that it's potential to do something - help the team win. That's what this is all about.
I mean this is the least offensive way possible but your unfounded opinion about what they could have done doesn't carry much weight. They picked who they wanted, the picks make sense to me, and theres absolutely nothing to prove that they could have traded down and gotten the same guys.