No one is asking him to break out. At $3.5 he's being paid like a #6 forward while to date he has produced like a #5. If he drops back to a #6, guess what? That's what he's being paid as.
And if he drops back to an 8 or 9? Because he got those 5 numbers playing with two of the better players in the NHL. So it’s fine if your plan is to let him play half his time with Tavares and Marner. But if not...