Napoli
Registered User
- Oct 4, 2023
- 968
- 1,041
The site is the same for everyone, people post hockey stat cards all the time after games in GameDay threads. I can't say I've disagreed with the data from those games. It's one thing to disagree but at least provide some data that says otherwise if you disagree. Werenski hasn't passed the eye test defensively and there are plenty of number "#1 dmen" on other bad or worse teams with much better defensive ratings. Please do your own research and fact check it.Take my comment as about the quality of evidence, not about your conclusion.
I looked at that site and every player on our team except for Jiricek and Olivier had a negative defensive rating. It's obviously a formula that struggles to disentangle team effects from player effects.
Call the data dependent on the team being good all you want but when other players on worst teams are better than Z defensively, that theory doesn't hold up.
Okay, show us data. You're making the claim. Back it up. Prove that he is the worst.
See my post above, Werenski is -4.5, go check other "#1 dmen" on worse teams, Seth Jones, Chychrun, Nurse, Brodin, Dahlin, Dunn, Karlsson, Hanifin, etc, those guys aren't anywhere close to -4.5. Hell, you could argue some of those guys aren't even #1 dmen, at least not proclaimed to be surefire #1 dmen the way Werenski is.