Shellz
Registered User
Have you seen his play this season? That's a trick question. I don't care to know. But, as always, not everybody is going to be happy. And Modry? Seriously. GTFO.
Kings News: Kings Trade Ehrhoff for Scuderi
- Thread starter TonySCV
- Start date
Have you seen his play this season? That's a trick question. I don't care to know. But, as always, not everybody is going to be happy. And Modry? Seriously. GTFO.
Shellz
Registered User
Shellz
Registered User
The fact remains.. I choose Scuderi every time. I don't expect him to be the same player. But, I can tel, he was respected and well liked around the dressing room and that's something we always have room for. Sure, it's depth, but it's depth the team can count on.
Minor Boarding
Registered User
Brown -retain some salary, add a pick, prospect like Zykov or/and Forbort
Clifford, Lewis - late pick
Raccoon Jesus
Todd McLellan is an inside agent
I only saw him play twice and he looked like he was skating in mud like before but his brain was also behind the play.
Honestly I think he's toast, even if he'd be insulated here, and I don't think he CAN be insulated with the d-core we have. Don't want him up the lineup with Doughty/Muzzin/Martinez, don't want him stuck with Schenn/McBain down the lineup either, though.
I guess Scuderi/Schenn on the PK?
Shellz
Registered User
I only saw him play twice and he looked like he was skating in mud like before but his brain was also behind the play.
Honestly I think he's toast, even if he'd be insulated here, and I don't think he CAN be insulated with the d-core we have. Don't want him up the lineup with Doughty/Muzzin/Martinez, don't want him stuck with Schenn/McBain down the lineup either, though.
I guess Scuderi/Schenn on the PK?
Hasn't he always looked like he skated in mud? I know he's not the same player but, Dean didn't bring him in for his play. I feel like everybody should know that by now.
Raccoon Jesus
Todd McLellan is an inside agent
And then who plays in their place?
Why are people suddenly ready to dump all our depth when they play our system to a T?
Ignore the advanced stats for a moment, even though Lewis/Brown/Shore play defense by being in the defensive zone about 1/3 of the time or less--there's a weardown effect there that's ESPECIALLY prevalent in a playoff series when we get our aggressive forecheck and cycle going. Guys like Brown and Lewis just absolutely destroy teams doing that and Shore has already joined them on that end. Do we want more production for them? Sure. But swapping them out for "more production" at THIS point is a shake up just for sake of a shakeup.
And while I understand the hate people sometimes have for our 4th line especially based on numbers, reality is we have one of the top 4th lines in the league, and one of the reasons people around here dislike them so much is simply because Sutter plays them so much compared to some 4ths around the league. They're arguably the 2nd best 4th line in the league at what they do because they're not JUST one dimensional.
HYORI 1963
Grit & Character
I only saw him play twice and he looked like he was skating in mud like before but his brain was also behind the play.
Honestly I think he's toast, even if he'd be insulated here, and I don't think he CAN be insulated with the d-core we have. Don't want him up the lineup with Doughty/Muzzin/Martinez, don't want him stuck with Schenn/McBain down the lineup either, though.
I guess Scuderi/Schenn on the PK?
Well, you've seen him for 2 games, which is 2 more games than I have. But guess what...I bet DL and his boys have seen him a whole lot more than you and I combined.
Raccoon Jesus
Todd McLellan is an inside agent
I'm not convinced. That they immediately sent Gravel down and are having Scuds join us tells me they're going to see what they have--which I don't' have a problem with--but I worry that sentimentality will get the best of our guys and he'll stick in the lineup.
I'm happy he's good in the room and honestly I'm generally happy he's back but as a #7 I hope...but I just think it's funny that one of the reasons we had such success early on was that we had 6 guys on D that could skate and move the puck. Getting Schenn was a step back away from that. Mayor suggesting Greene coming back is another redundancy. Getting Scuds is yet another. And none of those REALLY solve our RHD problem. And I worry we'll be seeing something like Doughty - McNabb / Muzzin - Schenn / Martinez - Greene come playoff time.
Raccoon Jesus
Todd McLellan is an inside agent
It's possible and I'd be thrilled to be wrong, I just...I'm playing the odds here. It's very unlikely.
Minor Boarding
Registered User
Yes I've seen Scuderi on both Penguins (vs. Flyers) and Blackhawks (vs Hurricanes and Yotes). He wasn't exactly a guy they could rely on-hence my Modry reference.
Little Psycho
I solemnly swear I'm up to no good
Great for the locker room, but at the end of the day they need another 3/4 defenseman cos Doughty can't handle all the load and Scuderi is not the answer.
Last edited by a moderator:
HYORI 1963
Grit & Character
I hope you're wrong as usual.
But even if you're not, the worst case scenario would be that he'll just ride the pine and be a good guy in the locker room.
deaderhead28
Registered User
- Jul 3, 2010
- 5,366
- 3,891
No ones jumping off bridges, but we're not homers either and see this doesn't make us better or make sense,since Blake has already made it known the Kings will not give up any high picks or high prospects to actually upgrade what we need to contend.So saving money on this deal is a waste of time when you're shopping for pylons and dumpster diving.I hope I'm wrong and Scuds actually does well.
Holden Caulfield
Eternal Skeptic
Minor Boarding
Registered User
Getting rid of Brown and Lewis is addition by subtraction. I felt the same way when we got rid of JJ and some around here were concerned we gave up a top 4 defensman.
Yeah they might know Sutter system but I look at guys like LeCavalier who learned it basically in a few games time. What Lewis and Brown showed thus far is unimpressive to say the least.
Yeah the 4th liners get too much ice time (and too many OZ starts for my liking).
Raccoon Jesus
Todd McLellan is an inside agent
I heavily disagree, and I think the JJ trade is a bad comparable in situation because he was immediately replaced with Voynov. Who replaces Brown and Lewis?
And you can't just leave advanced stats out of it, so i have to come back here--Lewis and Brown being so good at the zone control part of the game allows us to bring in a possession drain like Vinny to do his thing. Those 'tradeoffs' can be made from an analytics standpoint as we're still a crazy 3% higher than ANYONe else and more like 5-7% higher than the average team, but you have to bring in someone that can make that worthwhile (i.e. when we brought in Gaborik for scoring punch).
Raccoon Jesus
Todd McLellan is an inside agent
HYORI 1963
Grit & Character
SFKingshomer
Registered User
Reaper45
Registered User
Please explain how this would benefit the Kings and who you'd get to replace them?
Minor Boarding
Registered User
Replacing Brown and Lewis - plenty UFAs that actually have some production up their sleeve.
Corsi is fine and everything but Brown/Lewis offensive zone inabilities cost Kings points in the standings as well and they drag their lines to 0 offensive productivity. This isn't desirable for potential matches vs Ducks/Blackhawks...
scramble91
Registered User
- Jul 6, 2010
- 1,246
- 12
This move confuses me. I've watched scuderi the past 2 years and he has been absolute garbage 5on5. Which leads me to believe he will be a pk specialist to take minutes away from Martinez who is struggling with the heavier minutes (IMO). So plays maybe 7-8 mins a game. This will ensure Drew plays 30+ per game for the home stretch and playoffs.
His PK instincts have always been good so if he improves our PK then it could be a win/win thing for us. But those are some big "ifs"... Which is why I'm confused on the real reason.
