Here's my take on the "new Helle".
I don't think he's ready to take over as #1 just yet, and I'd prefer him to keep snagging wins as a backup while he cements some technical and physical changes, but if Mason can't climb back to his average I don't mind Helle taking on more games.
I think Helle has improved, for reasons that aren't necessarily congruent with his own self-assessment, but the proof is in the pudding. THIS save against Vancouver nearly had me jump out of my seat with joy, because I finally saw an important technical change
We can see Boeser tee up a shot from atop the hashmarks: Helle's nightmare zone that I've commented on extensively regarding his glove. But here he does something different! As he drops to make the save he uses a hybrid set position, specifically keeping his left pad up, forcing his glove hand to stay up! In one of my other posts I mentioned that if Helle wanted to keep his lower glove position he would need to maintain more active hands, or adopt this more hybrid style. I used Lundqvist as the only example of a goaltender that I've seen who has been really successful at this. And the similarity between Helle's save above and Lundqvist's type of save below is a very exciting improvement.
Even though the above save by Helle led to a rebound and PP goal, I was really excited as this is a positive sign of meaningful improvement. Connor himself, and the media, have started to talk about how he doesn't "go down" as much, but in truth I think that his adoption of this more hybrid style will indirectly improve his glove hand by forcing it to remain up as his body goes down (thus avoiding the major weakness in his glove position over the last two seasons).
Now.. Helle hasn't quite mastered this yet, and he has let in some stereotypical goals as last year. There are still examples of his previous play, such as on this breakaway against Minny:
Here Ferraro has a golden opportunity to score, and he's chosen to make a shot around the hash-marks which is Helle's achilles heel. I would prefer that Helle keep his glove slightly higher, though I like how it is more forward from his body. His glove, as it is, is not covering as much net from the puck as he thinks it is as we can see in the next frame:
At the moment of release we can see (in red) how Ferraro could have shelved this puck, forcing Helle to bring his arm upwards in a very difficult manor. A hybrid style save as the one he made above on Boeser could have helped and given him a chance, but I don't like this look. The green shows almost the entire top half open, though not necessarily all accessible from the puck's point of view. Thankfully Ferraro filled his gloves with cement and shot the puck into Helle's abdomen (in blue).
In the same game, we see Stewart with a great opportunity from the same dangerous spot:
Helle is playing a bit low here.. probably because he is anticipating a possible lateral move in case of a pass. Stewart was definitely selling the pass on this play. Nonetheless, his glove is still a bit low here for comfort. Had Stewart passed, Helle's glove would have sat on top of his pad as he would have needed to move laterally in butterfly position. The whole top half of the net would have been open. Stewart still has a good shot at the top corner, glove side, but Helle's positioning in this case takes much of that away since his torso is pretty square to the puck. This would be a way to positionally compensate for a lower glove as he would be relying on his shoulders to make the save in the event of a top corner shot. I don't like this look though, because I think Helle is this far over because he anticipates a pass, not because he's consciously using his frame to take away the glove side. Thankfully Stewart didn't test this theory out and opted for a 5-hole shot.
I think that Helle should keep rolling with the new hybrid style glove-side saves, and could benefit by consistently raising his glove up a bit more. Good things happen when he keeps his glove up, like in the game against Carolina:
This save got a huge cheer after Slavin undressed Tanev for a slap shot in Helle's no-no-zone. What is great here is that although he drops into a full butterfly, his glove position (in green) stays level and then moves up, despite his body moving down into butterfly (Blue line is just relative position of the post for comparison). Helle adds a little windmill action on the end of this for added flair, and the crowd eats it up. Even without the showmanship, this was a good example of proper glove technique in exactly the situation Helle struggled with last year.
But wait! There's more!
One other important part of all of this is the concept of "active hands". Helle is still keeping his glove low at times, but he is moving it forward and is also extending it purposefully in various directions to make saves. A good example of this is in the game against Minny:
Here Helle is battling a nasty screen. Instead of dropping into butterfly and waiting for the puck to get to him (hopefully somewhere on his body), he gets his glove out and actively catches the puck well in front of his body. The importance of this cannot be understated. Getting after the puck instead of waiting for it to hit you or reach your body will always give a better chance of a successful save. This is a very welcome change to Helle's game as he was more of a "set it and forget it" type of goalie in the past, thinking that he could just quickly square up and then the puck would hit him.
Although Helle is still demonstrating some previous technical flaws, his improvement this year has been largely due to the inclusion of hybrid style glove saves, sometimes higher glove position, and more active hands. This is why IMO Helle should continue to develop in a backup role where he can spend more time repping the things above that are giving him more success. Let him build up his muscle memory and technical responses in practice situations so that he can succeed in games intermittently. If he has a bad game, no worry, he can always use his time away from starts to work on something or continue solidifying technical improvements through increased reps. We should not succumb to the temptation to ride the hot hand because, as he is exposed to more of those dangerous shots in high pressure situations, he will regress back to older technique. Helle's potential could finally be realised this season, leading to a breakout year as a starter next season, as long as we don't burn him out thinking that he's ready to take the reins from Mason.
I'll get to Mason more fully another time, but we should use him as a starter and help him understand that he doesn't need to cover for the defence. If we try to make up for Mason's woes by using Helle more, we're going to run this team out of the playoffs for sure.