Value of: Hamilton

[FanTheFlames]

I'm wondering what people think Hamiltons value is? I keep seeing threads where people bash his value and argue if he is a top dman. When Calgary Aquired him they payed a mid 1st and 2 mid second rounders and in my opinion he is worth a fair bit more now. He is a young, cost controlled top 10 right handed dman in the nhl and in my opinion a top 20 dman. Looking for offers (What would your team give or what could he fetch) or value pick wise compared to what Calgary payed (worth another first etc...)

Click to read more...

 

[boredmale]

Islanders of offer Calgary's 1st, 2nd and 2nd in 2019

 

[FanTheFlames]

Islanders of offer Calgary's 1st, 2nd and 2nd in 2019

That im pretty sure would be an instant hang up considering Hamilton is a fair upgrade on Hamonic.

 

[boredmale]

That im pretty sure would be an instant hang up considering Hamilton is a fair upgrade on Hamonic.

Then I up it to our first(11), our 2nd(41) and Calgary's 2nd in 2019

 

[FanTheFlames]

Its better, but still really similar to what Calgary payed when they got him and he is a better player now then he was then and that was considered a reasonable price to pay then.

 

[boredmale]

Its better

I think you missed the joke given that our pick is like 1 better then Calgary's in the first and 2 picks better in the 2nd. Not sure that is a world of difference

I would say 50-50 chance you get the exact same guys you would pick in both deals

All that being said I would offer blindly 11+41+43 for Hamilton, but value might drop if you wait to see who is one the board at 11.

 

[Potty John]

Hamilton’s value is worth that of a top line forward with probably an add on top of that. How many right handed d-man can you name that are 6’6 can defend very well and put up 40-50 points a season.

 

[CraigsList]

Then I up it to our first(11), our 2nd(41) and Calgary's 2nd in 2019

We're not trading Hamilton for picks again. You could even offer up the 11th/12th OA combined and I'd still say no.

If you want Hamilton, we are going to be asking for Barzal. And I already know that asking for Barzal seems outlandish, but we are not going to trade Hamilton for anything less than a top 6 elite forward.

 

[Johnny Hoxville]

I think I’d only move Dougie for someone like Hischier, Nolan Patrick, Elias Pettersson, Matthews, Eichel or Barzal.

 

[Toby Flenderson]

I think I’d only move Dougie for someone like Hischier, Nolan Patrick, Elias Pettersson, Matthews, Eichel or Barzal.

Haha yikes

 

[Tkachuk Norris]

Haha yikes

The guy is third in 5 on 5 scoring over the past two seasons for defencemen (Karlsson and Burns have more).

He’s also comfortably in second in the NHL in shot differentials (behind Giordano) over the last two seasons.

I guess we should just give him away...

 

[Donuts]

Lucic

 

[Nopuckluck]

Zuccarello and Skjei

Hamilton and Fox

 

[Kranix]

Zuccarello and Skjei

Hamilton and Fox

Horrible.

 

[DFF]

Lucic

I think that's fair value

for Freddie

 

[13pacheco31]

I think I’d only move Dougie for someone like Hischier, Nolan Patrick, Elias Pettersson, Matthews, Eichel or Barzal.

I like how you throw Matthews, Eichle and Barzal in the there after Hischier, Patrick and Pettersson as if the later are equivalent to former. Those are two completely different tier of players lol

 

[Tkachuky]

Hamilton is too old. Hamilton gets carried by Gio. Hamilton is a cancer in the locker room. Hamilton is soft and bad defensively.

Hamilton’s value is nylanders jock strap.

 

[780il]

Puljujarvi + 10th Overall + 2019 1st (lottery protected) + Bear/Maximov + 40th Overall
For
Hamilton + Bennett

EDIT: I just remembered that Calgary has a lot of good young d prospects, so you could switch out Bear for Maximov, a rwer so they add more to there position of need.

 

[Critical13]

Hamilton is too old. Hamilton gets carried by Gio. Hamilton is a cancer in the locker room. Hamilton is soft and bad defensively.

Hamilton’s value is nylanders jock strap.

No one has said that. Drama queen!

 

[Critical13]

Puljujarvi + 10th Overall + 2019 1st (lottery protected) + Bear + 40th Overall
For
Hamilton + Bennett

That's not bad.

 

[780il]

That's not bad.

Yeah, I'd think a top 10 pick, high second rounder, another first, a young rwer with HEAPS of untapped potential, AND a good young d prospect is good.

 

[East Coast Icestyle]

That's not bad.

That's a bunch of unknowns and players/picks that could completely bust on us for the first or second best player on the flames and Bennet who... Meh.

Why are people so insistent on throwing Hamilton away or trading for him? Hell, I'd sooner trade Gaudreau.

 

[Critical13]

That's a bunch of unknowns and players/picks that could completely bust on us for the first or second best player on the flames and Bennet who... Meh.

Why are people so insistent on throwing Hamilton away or trading for him? Hell, I'd sooner trade Gaudreau.

I don't blame you, but I am just saying valuewise, I think it's not bad. 10th overall + 15th-20th overall, a high 2nd, Pool Party (I still have lots of hope) and Bear. Not an awful package.

I would only do that deal if you had to trade Hamilton for some reason tho, not on a whim. I still think Nylander for Hamilton is a good deal for both teams. 1 for 1, top line talents, positions of need.

 

[Rockmorton]

Lucic

You spelled Draisaitl wrong...

 

[SHANNYPLAN]

I think I’d only move Dougie for someone like Hischier, Nolan Patrick, Elias Pettersson, Matthews, Eichel or Barzal.

That’s quite the range of players