I think we put too much stock in the individual skills of defensemen. The bottom line is that hockey is a team sport, and the team plays as a five-player unit, all with the same goal. Sometimes, guys with more of certain skills work best when partnered with guys with opposite skill sets, sometimes, they work best with their mirror image. Nobody really knows how or why. Chemistry either happens or it doesn't. We really won't know until they play for a while.
Even the word "balanced" is inappropriate, IMO. We've got a bunch of good hockey players. Let's see how they play as a group.
And I may be the only one, but from a "hockey team" point of view and not a "hockey skills" point of view, I think Hainsey is an upgrade from Pitkanen.
Depending on what Murphy can bring I might not necessarily disagree with that. He's the big X factor for us this year since he's so new to this whole NHL thing. But I would have agreed before this move too. Faulk may be given more free reign too, and he's shown some serious offensive upside in the past IMO.
We basically swapped out McBain, Corvo, Sanguinetti, and MAB, a who's who of bad one-way guys where only McBain is salvageable, for Komisarek, Sekera, and... maybe Bellemore as the first callup? Now add Hainsey into that mix and this is a much much better defense at least as far as the primary concern for defensemen goes.
I honestly think Pitkanen's defensive abilities get a bad wrap, but Joni's problem was that he needs the right partner to play with: another semi-offensive oriented guy that can skate. Back when we had Seidenberg he and Joni made one hell of a pairing because both were good skaters, not too bad in their own zone, and Seids knew what he was doing offensively even if he wasn't super productive. McBain likewise actually worked with Pitkanen because he could skate and play offense, putting him with Joni made McBain look kindof competent, which is something no other defenseman in this org the last 5 years has been able to do with McBain.
Put Joni with a more defense oriented guy like Ward who's not a strong skater and doesn't have much offense to his game and, well, we've all see the Youtube video.
I've seen traffic cones that can break up a pass better than McBain and Sanguinetti.
Those were the drunks.