Value of: Galchenyuk (Blowout Edition)

[IWantSakicAsMyGM]

So your ask is Galchenyuk+1st+mete, that's more than a little absurd.

Downgrading from Duchene to Galchenyuk for less than that would also be absurd.

 

[David Suzuki]

Downgrading from Duchene to Galchenyuk for less than that would also be absurd.

stop it

 

[4thline]

It's how Habs fans characterized JVR for the last 2 years, regardless of his age Galchenyuk is of the same asset status- just less of a proven performer.

 

[HabsForHire]

For a guy who can't even crack Montreals top 6?

Wouldn't be chucky alone, galchenyuk + maccarron for nylander + pick ?

 

[blankall]

Lol Montreal fans are going to be very disappointed if Galchenyuk is traded. Duchene? Nylander? Wtf?

 

[loyaltotheend]

Matthews, Marner, or Nylander.
Anything else is a no.

Haha good one

 

[loyaltotheend]

Wouldn't be chucky alone, galchenyuk + maccarron for nylander + pick ?

Is this a joke post? Mac is hardly an nhler, and wouldn't make the Leafs. We have better players already waiting for a shot. Galchenyuk doesn't come close to Nylander, let alone adding a pick from Toronto.

No chance

 

[elitepete]

Granlund+Sutter for Galchenyuk

 

[Hostile Offer]

Mete is not expendable. Stop asking for him.

 

[Patagonia]

Galy playing 4th line minutes and extended for 3 years has lowered his value in a trade. They need a player like Duchene and without Sergachev not sure what they can offer to please the AVs looking for a LHD.

Galy
1st - 2017
Mete/Poehling/Juulsen

For

Duchene

 

[pockets]

Unless MTL has a young, potential top pairing LD then they're not landing Duchene. That's been Sakic's sticking point and I'd say it's pretty clear he's not backing off of that. Plus, Avs already have enough reclamation projects so I doubt they're ready to trade Duchene, who actual has good chemistry with his line mates for the first time in years and has been playing very well so far this season, to take on another problem child without addressing an actual need.

 

[HOPE]

Lol Montreal fans are going to be very disappointed if Galchenyuk is traded. Duchene? Nylander? Wtf?

Every trade are disappointed when your in the one in the bad position.

Just like the Duchene return will be disappointed, unless an other desperated team in the same situation shows up. As we speak i can only see Montreal in the same situation with chucky. I woulnt do more than 1 for 1 personnaly or would rather just keep him, but im afraid bergevin could actually go stupid and make overpayment.

 

[Hunter368]

Wouldn't be chucky alone, galchenyuk + maccarron for nylander + pick ?

Keep dreaming, no chance Leafseven consider that

 

[Sens of Anarchy]

Galy playing 4th line minutes and extended for 3 years has lowered his value in a trade. They need a player like Duchene and without Sergachev not sure what they can offer to please the AVs looking for a LHD.

Galy
1st - 2017
Mete/Poehling/Juulsen

For

Duchene

Change the / for a + and Sakic may listen

 

[HabsForHire]

Keep dreaming, no chance Leafseven consider that

I really dont think its terrible but for your sake chucky + lernout + 1st 19'

 

[ShelbyZ]

Just posted this in response to some AA/Galchenyuk chatter in the AA thread, seems relevant here as well...

AA (Unsigned RFA)
Sheahan (One year left @ $2.075M, RFA)
Mrazek (One year left @ $4M, RFA)
Along with either a slight bit of retained salary on Mrazek (Max $112.5K lol) and/or a pick for taking on his deal, or a conditional pick depending on Mrazeks future

for

Galchenyuk (3 years @ $4.9M, UFA)
Montoya (2 years @ $1.0625M, UFA)

DRW out - $6.075M
MTL out - $5.9625M

MTL gets AA who has a ton of upside and DET gets Galchenyuk, who might benefit from a change of scenery. For the rest, Sheahan gives MTL some flexibility. He can be a bottom 6 C that might be able to get back to his production from a couple seasons back with a change of scenery, or they can immediately flip him to the Pens or one of the other teams that have apparently inquired about him. Mrazek and Montoya are basically throw ins, with Mrazek clearing space for Galchenyuk for DET and Montoya giving the Wings serviceable NHL depth behind Howard. At the same time, there might be some potential reward with Mrazek. If he performs well as #2 behind Price, they can give him his QO and deal his rights to a team looking to give him a shot as a starter. If he's merely average/mediocre, they can let him walk as a UFA and grab another Montoya type on the UFA market.

Thoughts?

 

[CauZuki]

I really dont think its terrible but for your sake chucky + lernout + 1st 19'

Why would the leafs do this , they don't need bad picks in 2019. There team is almost ready to contend , they need complimentary players on offense and another solid top 4D.
Nylander has proven chemistry with Matthews , there is no add that Habs can realistically make to get Nylander.

 

[bsu]

What do you want from ducks?

 

[Bond]

If he can play RW, a slightly used Sam Bennett?

 

[Cousin Eddie]

Carl Soderberg 50% retained + JC Beaudin + 2018 2nd rounder for Galchenyuk.

 

[bleuetbio]

If he can play RW, a slightly used Sam Bennett?

Willing to add Valimaki and Lindgren/Mcniven?

I personnaly think that Galchenyuk would be a prolefic RW. He scored a lot on this side

 

[Liferleafer]

Wouldn't be chucky alone, galchenyuk + maccarron for nylander + pick ?

Is this real? You must mean the Buffalo Nylander....right?

 

[jfhabs]

Funny how a player can gain, lose, regain value in a 2/3/4 games span... Welcome to HF fellas

 

[LeapOnOver]

Just posted this in response to some AA/Galchenyuk chatter in the AA thread, seems relevant here as well...

AA (Unsigned RFA)
Sheahan (One year left @ $2.075M, RFA)
Mrazek (One year left @ $4M, RFA)
Along with either a slight bit of retained salary on Mrazek (Max $112.5K lol) and/or a pick for taking on his deal, or a conditional pick depending on Mrazeks future

for

Galchenyuk (3 years @ $4.9M, UFA)
Montoya (2 years @ $1.0625M, UFA)

DRW out - $6.075M
MTL out - $5.9625M

MTL gets AA who has a ton of upside and DET gets Galchenyuk, who might benefit from a change of scenery. For the rest, Sheahan gives MTL some flexibility. He can be a bottom 6 C that might be able to get back to his production from a couple seasons back with a change of scenery, or they can immediately flip him to the Pens or one of the other teams that have apparently inquired about him. Mrazek and Montoya are basically throw ins, with Mrazek clearing space for Galchenyuk for DET and Montoya giving the Wings serviceable NHL depth behind Howard. At the same time, there might be some potential reward with Mrazek. If he performs well as #2 behind Price, they can give him his QO and deal his rights to a team looking to give him a shot as a starter. If he's merely average/mediocre, they can let him walk as a UFA and grab another Montoya type on the UFA market.

Thoughts?

Makes sense as an outsider looking in

 

[Lebowski]

Just posted this in response to some AA/Galchenyuk chatter in the AA thread, seems relevant here as well...

AA (Unsigned RFA)
Sheahan (One year left @ $2.075M, RFA)
Mrazek (One year left @ $4M, RFA)
Along with either a slight bit of retained salary on Mrazek (Max $112.5K lol) and/or a pick for taking on his deal, or a conditional pick depending on Mrazeks future

for

Galchenyuk (3 years @ $4.9M, UFA)
Montoya (2 years @ $1.0625M, UFA)

DRW out - $6.075M
MTL out - $5.9625M

MTL gets AA who has a ton of upside and DET gets Galchenyuk, who might benefit from a change of scenery. For the rest, Sheahan gives MTL some flexibility. He can be a bottom 6 C that might be able to get back to his production from a couple seasons back with a change of scenery, or they can immediately flip him to the Pens or one of the other teams that have apparently inquired about him. Mrazek and Montoya are basically throw ins, with Mrazek clearing space for Galchenyuk for DET and Montoya giving the Wings serviceable NHL depth behind Howard. At the same time, there might be some potential reward with Mrazek. If he performs well as #2 behind Price, they can give him his QO and deal his rights to a team looking to give him a shot as a starter. If he's merely average/mediocre, they can let him walk as a UFA and grab another Montoya type on the UFA market.

Thoughts?

This boils down to AA for Galchenyuk, and it's not enough.