Kepley would be the gold standard for sure. Anyone that can put displaced fingers back into their sockets and then play the next set of downs is ok by me. I disliked him as an Eskimo, but loved him as a player, if that makes sense.
I’d like to nominate Wayne Shaw as runner up. Also Mr. Consistency at the linebacker spot, just in a different era. Oh, and a genuine nice person and so knowledgeable about the CFL, amongst other topics. I mean, he owned a bookstore in retirement for petes sake). Up until a few years ago he was a regular on the chat boards at Riderfans.com. It was always a pleasure to have him involved in a discussion.