Devils couldn't afford to give him 8 years, if he was willing to sign for 2-3 they would have considered bringing him back. I don't think it was the aav that scared people away as much as the term, 8 years is crazy.
This is absolutely true- 6.25 is reasonable value on the open market. Those 8 years are hideous though.
Fact is: he's really one of those Jake Gardiner lite types who can wow you with an outlet pass and then make the most boneheaded defensive play ever to lose a game.
The Devils would/could never pay him 6m though, even on shorter term. It doesn't make sense where the team is right now to be paying your #5 Dman that kind of money.
Before you all know better: I've literally spent the last ten years complaining about this guy's giveaways in post game threads. I've gone from touting him as our next great defenseman after seeing him play in the WHL, to absolutely praying for this day to finally come where I don't have to see him blow a tire, fan, fail to lock someone up or lose a puck battle in the corner.
This trade made two teams better today.
Edit: I WILL say that this year has absolutely been his best since his rookie year, despite reduced point production.