In comparison to their draft position this is not a great list at all.
That would imply they’d be better with the people taken a couple picks after. That gives them
Finley (Cogliano) - Oilers get much worse
Hamill (Gagner) - much worse
Cherepanov (Plante) - impossible to know
Blum (Nash) - worse
Tedenby (Eberle) - much worse
De haan (Paajarvi) - better
Gudbranson (Hall) - much worse
Huberdeau (Nuge) - pretty equal
Noeson (Klefbom) - much worse
Galchenyuk (Yakupov) - better
Horvat (Nurse) - pretty equal
Dal Colle (Draisaitl) - much worse
Strome (McDavid) - much worse
Tkachuk (Puljujarvi) - better
Vesalainen (Yamamoto) - too early
For some reason that doesn’t look as good to me. Or are you saying that any team sucks at drafting if they ever don’t take the player who ends up being the best possible player available at that slot?