randomhero4life
Registered User
When Windsor went to the Memorial Cups, they used a mixture of size and scoring to win the titles. Sure, they had guys like Hall, Henrique, and Wellwood, who were around the 6' mark with speed, but they also had guys like Greenop, MacDermid, and Young, who were 6'4. If you're smaller, you risk the run of being both intimidated and physically dominated by larger teams. If you're bigger, speed will eventually catch up to you.
Yes, OS has some smaller guys, but they also have guys like Schmalz (6'6), Gadjovich (6'2), Friend (6'2), and Cordell (6'2). It's a mixture and a proven formula.
Look at Erie - Strome (6'3), Pettit (6'4), Raddysh (6'2), Foegele (6'2), Cernak (6'3), Sambrook (6'2). They're going to beat you offensively but they can sure wear a team down with their size.
Going small isn't the answer. Going big isn't the answer. From what we've seen, a mixture seems pretty close to ideal.
I think the bigger forward trend started back in the day with Eric Lindros. Back in 1990 there were not a lot of forwards that were 6'3-6'6, 220 lbs -and up. Lindros was the new breed in terms of scouting, {big guy with big #'s) Size was always a plus when drafting defensemen, a lot of 1st rounder's back then were big defencemen (Darian Hatcher, Chris Pronger etc.) That trend continues today, but even bigger players being selected. Logan Stanley is the perfect example of what scouts are looking for in a defensemen, but all these guys like Big Stan all need to work on the skating abilities. Size just does not cut it anymore in today's NHL. The game has evolved dramatically over the last 20 years. Martin St. Louis is a great example, went undrafted due to his size, was a walk on invite. His career totals speak for themself. Showed that NHL scouts were wrong, they changed their scouting standards. in 2017 I believe size really is still the deciding factor, but just goes to show there are a lot of smaller players that can still crack the pro's. Teams scout for the perfect combination of size and skill, Villardi is a great example, 6'3 ,195 lbs, and he is 17.
Last edited: