With as many players looking lost as they do I would say this has to go on the coach. Tocchet still has proven no value as a NHL head coach. If we were seeing the players evolve and the team improve, then there could be some value there. Really the only difference we have seen from the team is slightly improved goaltending, but more is needed and possible. Waiting this long to name a captain has been detrimental given the circumstances.
There are several replacement level players on this team, and Domingue was at the top of that list to start the season. Kempe was worth a call-up, but not the stint he has pulled and at the cost of a player with potential like Duke. KConn and Schenn showed how thin the defense was after our top 4-5. There are likely others I am not inspired to remember to call out either.
I think there have been some bad decisions by management. The trades made sense at the moment, and everyone gave Chayka rave reviews for them. Having this kind of overhaul was likely a mistake. A culture change was needed, but they did not successfully install a new culture and likely have a worse one now than they did previously. Changing the coach, change the players, either of these changes could have been made and had an impact, but they did both and coupled that with dropping Doan the way they did.
At this point, does it really matter who is to blame though? This could start becoming more about solutions than blame, because the mistakes have been made. How do we fix this now?