What's the minimum return for which you'd trade Komarov at the deadline?

[BoredBrandonPridham]

For example, if you choose a late first, it means if there was a high second on the table for him you would walk away. The poll only has picks, but it could also be for comparable value prospect.

What do you think?

EDIT: Don't worry what you think someone would trade for him, it's what you'd give him up for.

EDIT2: I forgot an option for "No amount is enough", but would anyone not trade him for a top 5? Post in the comments if that's the case.

Click to read more...

 

[Eternal Leaf]

I wouldn't trade him unless the trade is something absurd (i.e top 15 pick).

He's only 28 and is such a great influence in the dressing room. You want players like him during the rebuild.

 

[tmlms13]

I'll take anything in the first round.

 

[BoredBrandonPridham]

I wouldn't trade him unless the trade is something absurd (i.e top 15 pick).

He's only 28 and is such a great influence in the dressing room. You want players like him during the rebuild.

Did you vote 15-30?

 

[Looney Toonies]

I'd want a first for the Korporal. But id still be hesitant to pull the trigger. His value is the highest it's ever been or possibly will be, but he seems like the perfect mentor for the new Leafs coming through the system. A fan favorite and rightfully so. Like most people will say, we'd need an overpayment.

 

[champs*]

whats amusing is those guys that picked top 5 actually believe he is worth that

 

[HamiltonNHL]

No Trade. Period.
/close thread.

 

[McMatthews]

Minimum: 2nd Rounder + 3rd Rounder
Ideal: 1st Rounder

 

[JimmyPower]

I can't vote. It would be a betrayal to the corporal.

 

[A1LeafNation]

Its important we dont fall in love with non-essential pieces during a rebuild. Sell high or dont sell at all if we dont have to.

 

[BoredBrandonPridham]

No Trade. Period.
/close thread.

What if I told you that we could trade for Komarov for 1st overall, and he doesn't even miss a Leafs game? Listen closely.

1. Leafs trade Komarov for 1st overall
2. The next day, the GM who traded away their 1st for Komarov gets fired
3. The Leafs trade back for Komarov with their 2nd (maybe throw in a 3rd to ease the blow) on that very day

 

[Warden of the North]

Mid-late 1st plus a third. Pretty much what we traded Versteeg for.

 

[Steveei]

I wouldn't trade him. You need a good character guy in the dress room, someone for the kids to learn from - an all around likable good guy, he is exactly that..

Any first round pick would be nice but idk.. hard to come across guys like Uncle Leo

 

[McMatthews]

I wouldn't trade him. You need a good character guy in the dress room, someone for the kids to learn from...

We have Mike Babcock now, so I'm not too worried about the kids learning the wrong way.

 

[Wafflewhipper]

There is no 2nd and 3rd option so i couldn't vote. Thats not saying i need to or want to move him. Leo is a homegrown and thats a cool thing for me to finally see him successful.

He's a keeper actually.

 

[BoredBrandonPridham]

There is no 2nd and 3rd option so i couldn't vote. Thats not saying i need to or want to move him. Leo is a homegrown and thats a cool thing for me to finally see him successful.

He's a keeper actually.

It's not possible to approximate to late first or early second as minimum value? That's some precise assessment there, sir or madam.

It's not a matter of need or want to move him, the questions is always for what?

There is a late first on the table. Do you take it?

What about top 15 then?

 

[BoredBrandonPridham]

I wouldn't trade him. You need a good character guy in the dress room, someone for the kids to learn from - an all around likable good guy, he is exactly that..

Any first round pick would be nice but idk.. hard to come across guys like Uncle Leo

I dunno, it feels harder to come across guys like Auston Matthews.

 

[Steveei]

I dunno, it feels harder to come across guys like Auston Matthews.

You're not getting a 1st overall pick for Komarov though.. any top 10 pick you 100% trade him, but is that realistic? No..

 

[Wafflewhipper]

It's not possible to approximate to late first or early second as minimum value? That's some precise assessment there, sir or madam.

It's not a matter of need or want to move him, the questions is always for what?

There is a late first on the table. Do you take it?

What about top 15 then?

No because i like him and you still have nothing to replace his game. I'm extremely bias because i like him. Now if i wanted to move him i would do that if there was a player there i wanted ha.

 

[hotpaws]

can't trade a player who's playing well because they're too valuable

can't trade a struggling player because you're selling low

Love Leo and hate saying this because he's the type of player this teams needs but if the right offer comes you move him since his value isn't going to get any higher .

 

[teeder333*]

Myself and a friend have made so many great predictions re: the Leafs and what they should have done. But you know what? Now, we can actually RELAX and watch the games and not worry about this stuff any more.

Why? Cause we literally have a hall of fame upper crust cast making the decisions now. It really is relaxing. A lot.

Sure mistakes will be made, but I don't hear anyone making any major whining noises about the moves on the last draft day.

Komarov is really really something, but the inner trust knows more than any of us now and that is great. Now the board can just concentrate on the smaller picture, like the game tonight.

Its soooo relaxing. It really is. Heck I might start smoking the green again before a Leaf game and let things just play out.

 

[ConnorTO]

just no

 

[RyanOhReally]

He holds more value to us than any trade

 

[Canada4Gold]

Voted top 15, which nobody would offer. Would take a 1st+prospect too assuming it's not a complete throw away prospect.

He's the type of player you keep so it'd have to be an overpay for what the other team thinks he's worth.

 

[CDP]

He has been great, and IMO his leadership/locker room presence separates him from rental/flip-at-TDL guys like Matthias and Parenteau

That said, he probably can't sustain this kind of production long-term, and this is literally the perfect time to sell high. If a 1st is on the table I would take it.