What would it take for you to move McDavid?

[Perfect_Drug]

To Montreal:
Jones+Forsberg+Ellis+1st

To Nashville:
2015 1st Overall Pick.

To Edmonton:
Weber + PK Subban at 50% Retained Salary



The likeliness of this happening is the likeliness of McDavid being Traded

 

[mc3488]

McDavid for Benn, Seguin and Klingberg is fair.

McDavid for Subban and Price too, IMO.

Wouldn't trade Benn or Seguin straight up. That trade is awful for dallas.

 

[Beerfish]

Wouldn't trade Benn or Seguin straight up. That trade is awful for dallas.

No, actually it is cheap for what would be asked.

To use the original topic line of the thread. Here is my answer. Take the worst offer you could imagine for your team and then add about 5 years of 1st round picks.

 

[Jimmi McJenkins]

Wouldn't trade Benn or Seguin straight up. That trade is awful for dallas.

Of course you wouldn't

 

[La Bamba]

I wouldn't trade McDavid for the entire Maple Leafs roster.

Dead serious.

 

[syz]

Wouldn't trade Benn or Seguin straight up. That trade is awful for dallas.

That's adorable.

 

[Calgary McOilers]

Wouldn't trade Benn or Seguin straight up. That trade is awful for dallas.

Poor Dallas! Their world would totally end if they were willing to give up Benn or Seguin for McDavid.

 

[5 14 6 1]

Like I've said many times.

Eichel + Risto +1st

Or

Ekblad + Barkov + 1st

Elite Player on ELC + another young valuable piece + a 1st

Aka it won't happen.

 

[Bangers]

Like I've said many times.

Eichel + Risto +1st

Or

Ekblad + Barkov + 1st

Elite Player on ELC + another young valuable piece + a 1st

Aka it won't happen.

These are the only trades that 'sort of' make sense for both teams, so yeah - not happening.

 

[Mc5RingsAndABeer]

Like I've said many times.

Eichel + Risto +1st

Or

Ekblad + Barkov + 1st

Elite Player on ELC + another young valuable piece + a 1st

Aka it won't happen.

I'd want more. I'd do something like Draisaitl + Nurse + 1st (mid) for Eichel all day.