Rumor: Trade rumors and proposals thread: Some witty title about Hamonic edition

[Raab]

Two trades I think make sense for both teams.

To NYI- Eberle

To Edm: Hamonic+Clutterbuck

To NYI: RNH

To Edm: Hamonic, Nielsen

 

[redgrant]

Two trades I think make sense for both teams.

To NYI- Eberle

To Edm: Hamonic+Clutterbuck

To NYI: RNH

To Edm: Hamonic, Nielsen

The second one doesnt make sense. RNH plays 23 minutes a night against the toughest opposition.

Lets quit pretending Hamonic is Karlsson or Subban.

 

[SDig14]

The second one doesnt make sense. RNH plays 23 minutes a night against the toughest opposition.

Lets quit pretending Hamonic is Karlsson or Subban.

Not to mention Nielsen could just leave and then we are back to having 2 legitimate offensive centers and poor depth down the middle.

 

[Joey Moss]

When we traded Pronger we got a young 28 goal scorer, a top 10 pick, a 1st, a 2nd and a conditional 1st/2nd. Thats hardly nothing, it's just unfortunate Lupul didn't turn out for us.

Edit: Its worth mentioning that the second 1st turned into Eberle I believe...

At the time that deal was much worse than what we were expecting to get. I remember people being disappointed that Getzlaf or Perry weren't part of the deal.

Whenever a player requests a trade the return is a disappointment. Always happens.

 

[Canovin]

At this point I want to see Yak+ traded for Hamonic. Tired of seeing the bashing this kid gets every game. Tavares will maximize Yak's potential

 

[Oilers10]

Yak has like no value. He has the same amount of goals as does Brandon Davidson. Let that sink in.

The only way NYI touches Yak is if they think he can be more playing with JT and basically because Garth is Garth.

And this is coming from a guy that likes Yak the man.

 

[Jumptheshark]

I'm mainly curious how JTS manages to type "Hamoric" all the time.

1) Big fingers little keybaord
2) Mostly type of cell phone
3) screw spell check
4) Its my thing

 

[Raab]

The second one doesnt make sense. RNH plays 23 minutes a night against the toughest opposition.

Lets quit pretending Hamonic is Karlsson or Subban.

Lets also quit pretending RNH is Toews. He's alright but people should realize he's ideally a number 2 centerman.

 

[Stud Muffin]

When we traded Pronger we got a young 28 goal scorer, a top 10 pick, a 1st, a 2nd and a conditional 1st/2nd. Thats hardly nothing, it's just unfortunate Lupul didn't turn out for us.

Edit: Its worth mentioning that the second 1st turned into Eberle I believe...

That second was Hamonic

 

[oilz89*]

In the cap world the only thing that would likely work is Yak and our 1st for Hamonic. Equal (ish) salary and would make us instantly better...but the thought of giving up that pick...

That pick would most likely get us a centre thats not as good as Connor McDavid.... so why bother when we have McJesus? Just trade the stupid thing. It has value. WIN NOW. Not in 6 years

 

[Staghorn]

This Oilers team is basically short a DMan that is capable and can play 22 min a night. One is available who actually wants to play in Edmonton. This is a big deal and big opportunity. Oilers have to win this sweepstakes. Alternative is waiting 1,2,3 years for Nurse to MAYBE turn into this guy, or drafting a guy who in 3,4,5 years can turn into this guy. Huge opportunity. RNH for Harmonic.

 

[Joey Moss]

At this point I want to see Yak+ traded for Hamonic. Tired of seeing the bashing this kid gets every game. Tavares will maximize Yak's potential

No.. McDavid will.

 

[Canovin]

No.. McDavid will.

But the top 6 is set. Oilers are building the team around these guys.

Hall-Drai-Purcell
Pou-RNH-Eberle

 

[Stud Muffin]

This Oilers team is basically short a DMan that is capable and can play 22 min a night. One is available who actually wants to play in Edmonton. This is a big deal and big opportunity. Oilers have to win this sweepstakes. Alternative is waiting 1,2,3 years for Nurse to MAYBE turn into this guy, or drafting a guy who in 3,4,5 years can turn into this guy. Huge opportunity. RNH for Harmonic.

And then...... There's a hole at Centre

 

[lakai17]

If Snow believes they are contenders which they are, I would go Eberle + (defenceman) for Hamonic + Pulock...

Snow wants a finisher we know.

Redeems the Reinhart trade. I like Reinhart but not for two draft picks in a solid draft.

 

[Raab]

The guy you're quoting hates RNH. RNH is one of the most underrated players in the NHL.

You can't be serious! So under rated he's helped this team out of the basement. RNH is the most over rated player on this board and city its pathetic. He's a good #2 who can fill the #1 slot. Theres a lot of guys who I would put ahead of RNH's as centres in the league. Also worth noting Frans Nielsen has the same amount of point as RNH and makes 3.25M less IIRC.

 

[Staghorn]

And then...... There's a hole at Centre

Luckily Drai has arrived and McDavid will be back. Sign a 3c. RNH is so overrated on this board its hilarious. If it wasnt for Yakupov he'd be one of if not the worst 1st overall pick in the last 20 years. Horrendous against top competition, and not going to gain the strength size or compete to be anything great. Drai has already passed him this season. Time to move on and address needs.

 

[Staghorn]

You can't be serious! So under rated he's helped this team out of the basement. RNH is the most over rated player on this board and city its pathetic. He's a good #2 who can fill the #1 slot. Theres a lot of guys who I would put ahead of RNH's as centres in the league. Also worth noting Frans Nielsen has the same amount of point as RNH and makes 3.25M less IIRC.

Last i checked Neilsen is better than 90% of oiler forwards.... if they could grab him too it would be a major coup.

 

[Narnia]

You can't be serious! So under rated he's helped this team out of the basement. RNH is the most over rated player on this board and city its pathetic. He's a good #2 who can fill the #1 slot. Theres a lot of guys who I would put ahead of RNH's as centres in the league. Also worth noting Frans Nielsen has the same amount of point as RNH and makes 3.25M less IIRC.

RNH is underrated because of the constant RNH bashing on this board.. I'm getting fed up of the RNH bashing.

 

[Stud Muffin]

Luckily Drai has arrived and McDavid will be back. Sign a 3c. RNH is so overrated on this board its hilarious. If it wasnt for Yakupov he'd be one of if not the worst 1st overall pick in the last 20 years. Horrendous against top competition, and not going to gain the strength size or compete to be anything great. Drai has already passed him this season. Time to move on and address needs.

Now we know how terrible a judge of talent you are.

 

[Raab]

But the top 6 is set. Oilers are building the team around these guys.

Hall-Drai-Purcell
Pou-RNH-Eberle

Mcdavid? I think its look more like:

Hall-Drai-? (Purcell is not the long term solution)
Pouliot-Mcdavid-? (Yak has shown he can produce and is making an affordable 2.5 next season)

RNH can be moved, Eb's can be moved or fill in on the top line. Yaks can be kept worst case scenario and is an affordable winger for Mcdavid.

 

[The Head Crusher]

Green Eggs and Hamonic

 

[Staghorn]

RNH is underrated because of the constant RNH bashing on this board.. I'm getting fed up of the RNH bashing.

RNH is a horrible perimiter player. Like that kid who killed bantam but sucks in midget, he is in over his head. Compete level is questionable too. I have yet to be impressed, and for one am always shocked at how much positive commentary he gets on here. He is a weak NHler.

 

[Staghorn]

Now we know how terrible a judge of talent you are.

Proof is in the pudding Bro... He is 40lbs too small and always has played light. Terrible pick, but thats hindsight. What has he done exactly the past what? 2 years?? Major dissapointment.

 

[lakai17]

Hamonic + Nelson

Or

Hamonic + Lee

For

Eberle + Schultz