Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread Part XI

[MarkovsKnee]

Would Petry and our 1st get us Tkachuk from the Sens?

No.

 

[cphabs]

Thanks everyone. Just curious.

 

[BaseballCoach]

If they move out Ward, I would guess they’ll be in the market for a rental goalie that’s a lot better then Niemi. Ward’s been playing decent for them as of late. Niemi does nothing for them.

If you read the article I linked, the Hawks believe Crawford is back and Dellia can be the backup. Niemi would be the third goalie.

 

[sheed36]

Would we?

Lets ask the magic conch.

 

[Runner77]

Thanks everyone. Just curious.

I may have misread you. I wasn't sure about the ambit of the question. I agree with the answer given.

However, Petry and our first would get good traction without it having to be Tkachuk. Also, Petry as a standalone would have great value given his season and how top 4 RHDs are highly valued. We could keep the pick and still make a nice return with Petry alone.

 

[Mrb1p]

Just use the wingers we have better.

Drouin-Danault-Gallagher
Byron-Domi-Shaw
Tatar-Kotkaniemi-Armia
Lehkonen-Poehling-Suzuki/Weise

Lehkonen can still be one of the top 4 penalty killers.

Why is our best player getting the worst wingers? Jeez.

 

[cphabs]

I may have misread you. I wasn't sure about the ambit of the question. I agree with the answer given.

However, Petry and our first would get good traction without it having to be Tkachuk. Also, Petry as a standalone would have great value given his season and how top 4 RHDs are highly valued. We could keep the pick and still make a nice return with Petry alone.

What does “ambit” mean?

 

[Ozmodiar]

Would Petry and our 1st get us Tkachuk from the Sens?

Came to browse the thread, then read this. I’m out.

 

[Runner77]

What does “ambit” mean?

Scope. Anyways, it's been answered, I don't want to belabor it.

 

[cphabs]

Scope. Anyways, it's been answered, I don't want to belabor it.

Good enough.

 

[FF de Mars]

I have this dream of trading Weber for Nylander and Zaitsev (to balance salary cap); or, something along those lines. Nylander is stuck behind a talented forward corp, Babcock is being old school. You go with Kotkaniemi and Nylander as 1A and 1B, Domi on the wing where he's even more effective. This instantly makes the team better, at the very least more talented. "Sois clairevoyant", Bergevin!

 

[Dichow Stopper]

I have this dream of trading Weber for Nylander and Zaitsev (to balance salary cap); or, something along those lines. Nylander is stuck behind a talented forward corp, Babcock is being old school. You go with Kotkaniemi and Nylander as 1A and 1B, Domi on the wing where he's even more effective. This instantly makes the team better, at the very least more talented. "Sois clairevoyant", Bergevin!

Trading Weber doesn’t instantly makes the team better, especially when you consider the issues we already have with our defense.

 

[OldCraig71]

Are we really going to sell any players though? What did we do last year when we were basically out of it by the end of November? I don't see Bergevin making any major deals to ship out the likes of Petry, Tatar or Byron, he won't do it. He will look at this year as a positive and something to build on, he won't upset the culture of this team and basically we do nothing again.

 

[The Great Weal]

Are we really going to sell any players though? What did we do last year when we were basically out of it by the end of November? I don't see Bergevin making any major deals to ship out the likes of Petry, Tatar or Byron, he won't do it. He will look at this year as a positive and something to build on, he won't upset the culture of this team and basically we do nothing again.

We traded all our ufas which was the right call

 

[BaseballCoach]

Why is our best player getting the worst wingers? Jeez.

If you mean Poehling, it's because he's young. LOL, just kidding.

I guess you mean Domi, and as I wrote elsewhere, I would actually as a second part of this move switch up Byron and Drouin. I think eventually Domi and Drouin are back together, and Shaw is a good complement for them even though Gallagher is a better goal scorer. Gallagher has proven he can score off almost any line.

So, for next year, this is what I would do, first step in KK's progress to 1C is moving KK to 2nd center, and also hoping two rookies can make it, sooner or later:

1. Drouin-Domi-Shaw
2a. Tatar-Kotkaniemi-Armia
2b. Byron-Danault-Gallagher
4. Lehkonen-Poehling/stop-gap-Suzuki/Weise

 

[L4br3cqu3]

Dallas - Roope Hintz, Denis Guryanov
Carolina - Julien Gauthier, Nicolas Roy

Just throwing names out there, the type of prospect forward I'd look for if we were going to trade Tatar/Petry, we need size and skill on the wings. (although Roy is more a C than a W, and probably wouldn't cost as much as the others, but hey)

 

[eklund the clown]

I have this dream of trading Weber for Nylander and Zaitsev (to balance salary cap); or, something along those lines. Nylander is stuck behind a talented forward corp, Babcock is being old school. You go with Kotkaniemi and Nylander as 1A and 1B, Domi on the wing where he's even more effective. This instantly makes the team better, at the very least more talented. "Sois clairevoyant", Bergevin!

Been saying the same on here for months.Makes sense for both teams.

 

[CHarlie]

What would it cost us to get Panarin only if he was to sign with us.....hes going to get 8-9million. He is exactly what we need.

 

[BaseballCoach]

I have this dream of trading Weber for Nylander and Zaitsev (to balance salary cap); or, something along those lines. Nylander is stuck behind a talented forward corp, Babcock is being old school. You go with Kotkaniemi and Nylander as 1A and 1B, Domi on the wing where he's even more effective. This instantly makes the team better, at the very least more talented. "Sois clairevoyant", Bergevin!

Your dream is my nightmare.

Zaitsev is not a need for us. Nylander may be a very good forward but again, we don't need to trade for him to put him at C to score 70 points, but also "trade" 70 point center Domi for a 9-goal Domi playing LW. Seems to me all we have done here is downgrade from Weber to Zaitsev at RD without getting an elite goalscorer or a strong LD.

 

[le_sean]

Yeah trade Weber to the Leafs and hand them the Cup. Worst move ever.

 

[ECWHSWI]

Yeah trade Weber to the Leafs and hand them the Cup. Worst move ever.

is that a fact ?

 

[OldCraig71]

We traded all our ufas which was the right call

But nothing of significance which was my point, I should have been clearer.

 

[FedorTyutin]

I don't know if this has been discussed but would Huberdeau vs Drouin 1 for 1 work for both teams?

Similar contract, similar productions, both had issues with coach lately... I normally don't wish to trade guys that have good productions but have a bad sequence, however, I'm wondering if in Bergevin or Julien's mind it could be a solution for Panthers and Habs.

Panthers get the younger player, Habs get the more consistent... Who adds if necessary?

 

[Ozmodiar]

I don't know if this has been discussed but would Huberdeau vs Drouin 1 for 1 work for both teams?

Similar contract, similar productions, both had issues with coach lately... I normally don't wish to trade guys that have good productions but have a bad sequence, however, I'm wondering if in Bergevin or Julien's mind it could be a solution for Panthers and Habs.

Panthers get the younger player, Habs get the more consistent... Who adds if necessary?

dare to dream.

 

[OldCraig71]

What would it cost us to get Panarin only if he was to sign with us.....hes going to get 8-9million. He is exactly what we need.

We wont be making a pitch for any star Russian players.