Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
Why not use Poehling instead of Brooks?
I was thinking about this. I just wonder. Who do you trade if your are forced to? Pick one: Romanov, Poehling, or Brook?
Why not use Poehling instead of Brooks?
I would say NO.I'm with you on Primeau. He can possibly replace Price when Price is in year 6/8 of his contract (age 36) or be a solid backup. When Price is 36, Primeau is 24. We just don't know how good he is yet in terms of being a NHL starter.
Lets say the Sens ask for Primeau, Lehkonen, and our 1st for Duchene in a sign and trade? Do you say no?
I'd prefer not trading any prospects or picks, personally.
But, let's say I had to choose one of our top prospects, I think I'd trade Suzuki before Poehling, Brook and Romanov...
Seems a pretty fair trade to me.
Would definitely hesitate before doing that, I'm high on Brook
Not sure why Panthers would move him. Good cap hit.
Byron, Poelhing, 2019 1st and Arizona 2019 5th for Duchene and Ryan
Yes, sorry am cooking dinnerBecause Primeau is involved?
Yes, sorry am cooking dinner
Poehling cuz with Danault Domi Koko i'm happy right now and i'm sure we can pick another good young c at the draft. D-man is suck a priority tha we shouldn't touch them yet!I was thinking about this. I just wonder. Who do you trade if your are forced to? Pick one: Romanov, Poehling, or Brook?
Imo. You don’t touch to romanov. Montreal are very weak on LD. And what i see in wjc for a young men like him, impress me a lot. Poehling, have a high floor. So hes gonna play in the nhl, maybe like a second or third line, but he has size, what we miss here too. So, the obly one with a lot of value is josh brook, but if we trade him, we have to acquire a young player, preferably with terms. Thats my opinionI was thinking about this. I just wonder. Who do you trade if your are forced to? Pick one: Romanov, Poehling, or Brook?
Duchene is a small 28 year old forward that will be retired we actually have a cup contending team. I would NOT trade a 1st let alone Primeau for him. Petry? Sure!No worries. Just curious and wanted to confirm. So some have Primeau as untouchable like Romanov, Poehling, Brook. I have him with Suzuki personally. I like him a lot but I'm also not ignoring the chance at acquiring a player with term who makes our team better today.
We are in a Re-Set, not a full rebuild.
Nick suzuki is the type of guy whos have a really high roof, but a low floor. Hes not the fastest, but hes doing all little things right and its very rare that hes making the wrong play. A guy like him whos dominating the junior since he is 17 years old, we have claude giroux...
Byron, Poelhing, 2019 1st and Arizona 2019 5th for Duchene with extension and Ryan.
Fully agree, but keep in mind we are discussing a hockey trade here in this case, not a rental.I will bet my left nut (with anyone but LOLwhiteknight aka Monkza) that our 1st and top 4 prospects are completely off the table. We’re still in rebuild mode and sticking up in assets. With the number of UFAs likely available and young players we need to fit into the lineup, there’s no chance Bergevin backs out of what he’s been saying for over a year now of building for the future and stockping picks. This is not our year to go for a Cup run.
Fully agree, but keep in mind we are discussing a hockey trade here in this case, not a rental.
I hope your right. It isn't the year to go for it.I will bet my left nut (with anyone but LOLwhiteknight aka Monkza) that our 1st and top 4 prospects are completely off the table. We’re still in rebuild mode and sticking up in assets. With the number of UFAs likely available and young players we need to fit into the lineup, there’s no chance Bergevin backs out of what he’s been saying for over a year now of building for the future and stockping picks. This is not our year to go for a Cup run.