Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread: Off-season Editon

[sampollock]

Habs need scoring, have forever
No time now to trade for 30 point forwards,

 

[sampollock]

Maxy should bring a nice haul, you would hope

 

[Vachon23]

Last week LeBrun said Arizona called Montreal about moving up. Sportsnet mentioned Max Domi and #5 overall pick for #3 overall pick. This week TSN mentioned Noah Hanifin for a first round pick. I would be surprised if we do a three way trade to get Hanifin and Domi.

To Arizona: #3 overall pick
To Montreal: Max Domi and #5 overall pick

To Carolina: #5 overall pick
To Montreal: Noah Hanifin

Not sure Arizona make this deal.. Max Domi is a top 6 player in the NHL and he is young. I think Merkley + 5th overall would be more realistic

To Arizona: #3 overall pick
To Montreal: #5 overall pick + Nick Merkley

 

[OB5]

So I did one of those GM games and was the Habs and decided to do a rebuild. Here are the trades I was able tp pull off with other people:

Trades:

receives:

Alex Galchenyuk and the 38th overall pick 2018 (originally Chicago's pick)

receives:

8th overall pick 2018

-----

Acquire

Nicolas Deslauriers
Brendan Gallagher

Acquire

Robert Thomas
1st 2018 (29th overall, WPG pick)
4th 2018 (107th)
Tage Thompson
-------

acquires

Andrew Shaw (40% retained)

acquires

Dmytro Timashov
Justin Holl

-------


Pacioretty 50% retained
Weber 20% retained



Borgstrom
FLA 2019 1st
FLA 2018 3rd
Heponiemi
McCoshen
Hawryluk
McGinn

-------

send
#11
#28
Andrew MacDonald

send
2019 1st (FLA)
#35

 

[Milhouse40]

Not OK with it. The point was what decision do you make if you don't get your asking price? Do you keep him or take the best offer at the draft? Cause you know why? The offer is not going to be better next trade deadline.

What's weird is not understanding this and expecting we will automatically get our high asking price in return when we didn't get it at the last deadline and it included one playoff run

Rick Nash, which has around 40pts seasons in his last 3 seasons and barely crack 20 goals, as a location player was traded for:
Ryan Spooner (45-50pts young center) + Ryan Lindgren + 1st round pick + 7th round pick and a cap dump (Beleskey)

If Bergevin can't get creative and find a to get what he needs, then he should not be the GM.
Even freaking Hanzal cost a 1st round pick as a location player.

If it's the best offer Bergevin has for Paciorretty, then don't trade Pacioretty, don't sign him long-term.....just fire Bergevin.

 

[Vachon23]

So I did one of those GM games and was the Habs and decided to do a rebuild. Here are the trades I was able tp pull off with other people:

Trades:

receives:

Alex Galchenyuk and the 38th overall pick 2018 (originally Chicago's pick)

receives:

8th overall pick 2018

-----

Acquire

Nicolas Deslauriers
Brendan Gallagher

Acquire

Robert Thomas
1st 2018 (29th overall, WPG pick)
4th 2018 (107th)
Tage Thompson
-------

acquires

Andrew Shaw (40% retained)

acquires

Dmytro Timashov
Justin Holl

-------


Pacioretty 50% retained
Weber 20% retained



Borgstrom
FLA 2019 1st
FLA 2018 3rd
Heponiemi
McCoshen
Hawryluk
McGinn

-------

send
#11
#28
Andrew MacDonald

send
2019 1st (FLA)
#35

Wooo you robed them ! Haha

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

This dude just asked for Andre Macdonald . pls kill me

 

[OB5]

This dude just asked for Andre Macdonald . pls kill me

Actually it was offered to me. I took his contract on to get the 2 first rounders.

I ended up with 5 first round picks in the 2018 draft.

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

Actually it was offered to me. I took his contract on to get the 2 first rounders.

I ended up with 5 first round picks in the 2018 draft.

trading galchy for a 1st pick is pretty bad , there is 0 point to do that also.

 

[OB5]

trading galchy for a 1st pick is pretty bad , there is 0 point to do that also.

The pick ended up being Quinn Hughes so...yeah.

 

[Vachon23]

The pick ended up being Quinn Hughes so...yeah.

Who where the other pick ?

 

[OB5]

Who where the other pick ?

Here was my full draft class.

First 5 picks were made by me live, the last 6 were done through a list. They only did rounds 1-4.

3-Filip Zadina
8-Quinn Hughes
11-Ty Smith
28-Jake Wise
29-K’Andre Miller

Ruslan Iskhakov
Semyon Der-Arguchintsev
Jack Drury
Filip Johansson
Curtis Hall
Damien Giroux

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

The pick ended up being Quinn Hughes so...yeah.

and u could get a good D in return of Galchy instead of drafting a unknown potential derp

 

[OB5]

and u could get a good D in return of Galchy instead of drafting a unknown potential derp

I went rebuild, other people in other games bought up...I went rebuild.

Anyways, aside from grumpy gus over here who clearly hates life...any thoughts on these completely realistic trade proposals?

 

[Vachon23]

and u could get a good D in return of Galchy instead of drafting a unknown potential derp

Hanifin ?

 

[HabsWhiteKnightLOL]

Hanifin ?

Could be a great base for him atleast.

 

[Sterling Archer]

So I did one of those GM games and was the Habs and decided to do a rebuild. Here are the trades I was able tp pull off with other people:

Trades:

receives:

Alex Galchenyuk and the 38th overall pick 2018 (originally Chicago's pick)

receives:

8th overall pick 2018

-----

Acquire

Nicolas Deslauriers
Brendan Gallagher

Acquire

Robert Thomas
1st 2018 (29th overall, WPG pick)
4th 2018 (107th)
Tage Thompson
-------

acquires

Andrew Shaw (40% retained)

acquires

Dmytro Timashov
Justin Holl

-------


Pacioretty 50% retained
Weber 20% retained



Borgstrom
FLA 2019 1st
FLA 2018 3rd
Heponiemi
McCoshen
Hawryluk
McGinn

-------

send
#11
#28
Andrew MacDonald

send
2019 1st (FLA)
#35

 

[blarneylad]

So you keep him then if you don't get your asking price? You can make your own point all you want. At the end of the day we are making two separate points.

Circumstance needs to work in our favor if we are getting our high asking price for Patch. I'm not saying we should set the bar high. I'm saying what is the plan if we don't get the offer we expect to get. Keep him and re-sign him? Trade him at the next draft for a lesser return than what we can get this next draft?

What are you prepared to do if you don't get what you think you can get. This is the point.

Wait until this upcoming trade deadline and move him.

You don't have to trade him right away, and if you do trade him you need to aim higher than a slow third liner and a 15th

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

Lebrun confirms habs have zero interest in getting Lucic

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

Lebrun confirms habs have zero interest in getting Lucic

Insider trading ?

 

[sheed36]

Lebrun confirms habs have zero interest in getting Lucic

Lebrun is on TSN690 with Melnick right now so maybe he'll mention it there as well.

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

Insider trading ?

yea

 

[Runner77]

Lebrun is on TSN690 with Melnick right now so maybe he'll mention it there as well.

Lebrun: "I'm all right, I'm all right, I'm all riiiiiiiiiiiiiight."

 

[Gaylord Q Tinkledink]

yea

Just watched the clip and Lebrun does say that. He also mentions the oilers are trying to get a hockey deal done with Lucic.

 

[Runner77]

Chiarelli is delusional. As per Lebrun, his attitude is "we're not giving Lucic away, it needs to be a hockey deal", as per Lebrun.

And reconfirms how Montreal won't be in play.