HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #82
- Thread starter MarkovsKnee
- Start date
- Status
SlyIslands
Registered User
I'm not sure Buffalo has no goalie depth, yes in the NHL but they have some prospects. They have Levi, Luukkonen and Portillo. I could see them trade one
- Jun 24, 2012
- 83,853
- 150,986
FWIW, crusty ole pundit Yvon Pedneault confirms that Edmondton no longer has an active interest in Edmundson. Says so here: Chronique d'Yvon Pedneault - BPM Sports
No big deal, there should be others interested by the trading deadline.
No big deal, there should be others interested by the trading deadline.
Edmundson => Hopefully traded, but I fear Hughes believe they have to keep him
Monahan => Traded unless Dvorak is at the deadline instead
Dvorak => Traded before his NTC apply, but Hughes might be inclined to keep him since the team has zero center depth
Anderson => Hopefully traded, but won't happen
Hoffman => Gonna keep him
Drouin => A team is going to give something for him?
Dadonov => Ditto
Savard => Keeping until the RHD prospects are NHL ready
Hughes will draft a goalie, they won't trade for a goalie prospects unless a team needs LD prospects in exchange...we got plenty of those still, not much of anything else.
Monahan => Traded unless Dvorak is at the deadline instead
Dvorak => Traded before his NTC apply, but Hughes might be inclined to keep him since the team has zero center depth
Anderson => Hopefully traded, but won't happen
Hoffman => Gonna keep him
Drouin => A team is going to give something for him?
Dadonov => Ditto
Savard => Keeping until the RHD prospects are NHL ready
Hughes will draft a goalie, they won't trade for a goalie prospects unless a team needs LD prospects in exchange...we got plenty of those still, not much of anything else.
Habs Halifax
Loyal Habs Fan
I think Gorton/Hughes would prefer to move Eddy and at full cap hit but I think their best play is to advertise a 50% retention about 1 week before the deadline. That's how we might get the 1st rounder. I'm not buying that we should get a 1st cause Savard and Chiarot got one. It's usually circumstantial.
Teams won't trade their first until they have a good idea where it will be. So maybe this picks up in Jan/Feb.
If there is no retention, I do think we can get two 2nd rounders but once again, closer to the deadline
Team_Spirit
95% Elliotte
- Jul 3, 2002
- 37,718
- 17,543
I don't buy these goalie rumors Hughes just re-upped all the 3 goalies for 2 years and we have Dobes already who is just behind Levi stats wise in the ncaa.
The standings are tight by design that leave the numbers of teams selling low so Kent will make out like a bandit again this year. Lfg
The standings are tight by design that leave the numbers of teams selling low so Kent will make out like a bandit again this year. Lfg
sampollock
Registered User
Would love to land a good goalie prospect.
To add to the young movement
To add to the young movement
bcv
My french sucks.
- Sep 18, 2010
- 4,570
- 2,537
Yvon Pedneault has as much credibility as Eklund or that hockeyinsiderrrrr guy
- Jun 24, 2012
- 83,853
- 150,986
Hence, the FWIW in my post. Still a mainstream guy but his contacts must be mostly stale — he’s definitely not a top dog.
- Jun 24, 2012
- 83,853
- 150,986
I want to see Hughes break his no retention rule on multi year contracts before believing that he will.
Regardless, he shouldn’t have to retain on Edmundson since he has a low cap hit and the acquiring team can recoup its investment thanks to that 2nd contract year, by having the ability to flip him for likely similar value in 2023-24 than what they’d be coughing up for him now.
Last edited:
Sterling Archer
Registered User
- Sep 26, 2006
- 22,978
- 13,449
I do. It was rumoured they were looking for a true no. 1 starting goalie before last years TDL. Samsonov was rumoured as was the fact Hughes even said Habs didn’t have a real no. 1 at the moment.I don't buy these goalie rumors Hughes just re-upped all the 3 goalies for 2 years and we have Dobes already who is just behind Levi stats wise in the ncaa.
The standings are tight by design that leave the numbers of teams selling low so Kent will make out like a bandit again this year. Lfg
SlafySZN
Registered User
- May 21, 2022
- 6,727
- 14,445
The thing is that they don't need a ''true #1'' for a few years.
Sterling Archer
Registered User
- Sep 26, 2006
- 22,978
- 13,449
All the better a time to get a young goalie to develop into one along with the rest of the core. That way they all hit their peak years at the same time.
sampollock
Registered User
When is that winning switch gonna be activated?
In goals Primeau is already 23, Dobes 21.
defense 4 guys between 20-22.
forwards 4 guys between 18-23.
probably 2 prospects with nice odds both at fwd and d around 18
thats half a team (and no goalie). You still need good 24-26 yrs old players. Huge hole as of now
Galchenyuk15
Registered User
- Jan 2, 2013
- 165
- 136
Not really a good trade in a rebuild, I will try to obtain a 1st round pick and/or a prospect but if it's not the case. I'm ready to try another option!
To Montréal :
Anthony Mantha - 28 years - 2 years at 5,700,000$
To Washington :
Josh Anderson - 28 years - 5 years at 5,500,000$
Jan Mysak
Mantha : Maybe in Montréal under MSL he can be sucessful and playing with more passion; one of his major flaws. If the experience don't succeed you can still trade him at the 2023 deadline. At least, Mantha can be use in a offensive way!
Anderson : I don't know how to use him. Not a point producer, not a shutdown guy, can't really find a chemistry with anyone. Looking much better on the paper than the ice! For me the Josh Anderson Project is a total failure!
Mysak : I never really like this prospect for all the experience he have at every stage versus the others players of his age, he needs to show a lot more than that and he didn't do that. It's a question of time before he disappear in your hierarchy!
If Mantha stay at long term and the Habs add Dubois in the 2024 UFA market!
Caufield-Suzuki-Dach
Slafkovsky-Dubois-Mesar
Farell-Beck-Mantha
Gallagher-Dvorak-Heineman-Pick 2023
To Montréal :
Anthony Mantha - 28 years - 2 years at 5,700,000$
To Washington :
Josh Anderson - 28 years - 5 years at 5,500,000$
Jan Mysak
Mantha : Maybe in Montréal under MSL he can be sucessful and playing with more passion; one of his major flaws. If the experience don't succeed you can still trade him at the 2023 deadline. At least, Mantha can be use in a offensive way!
Anderson : I don't know how to use him. Not a point producer, not a shutdown guy, can't really find a chemistry with anyone. Looking much better on the paper than the ice! For me the Josh Anderson Project is a total failure!
Mysak : I never really like this prospect for all the experience he have at every stage versus the others players of his age, he needs to show a lot more than that and he didn't do that. It's a question of time before he disappear in your hierarchy!
If Mantha stay at long term and the Habs add Dubois in the 2024 UFA market!
Caufield-Suzuki-Dach
Slafkovsky-Dubois-Mesar
Farell-Beck-Mantha
Gallagher-Dvorak-Heineman-Pick 2023
Scintillating10
Registered User
Price must be high on Edmunston. I thought Habs might not trade him unless blown away. With 4 rookies on defense and Eddy signed for next year.
I would not take anything Pedneault says seriously. I don't believe him or any supposed sources he has.
DailyKaizen
Registered User
Is Mantha a good fit? I like his pros but I heard of his cons and do not know if they outweigh his positives...
It is likely HuGo will target what we would call projects with whatever assets we trade away, when I say"projects" I mean more under the radar type of players that are former clients.
Guiness time
Registered User
- Mar 14, 2007
- 307
- 165
Please add Evans to your list. i would be happy with a 2050 3rd round pick. I'll probably be dead to see the return, but still be happy with it.
Gaylord Q Tinkledink
Registered User
- Apr 29, 2018
- 29,576
- 31,117
No. He's basically Anderson but can't fight as well as Anderson can
bsl
Registered User
- Oct 9, 2009
- 10,107
- 3,322
Unless the goalies they draft are very very good prospects, none of them will see regular play in NHL for 5 years. Too late. Hugo will go after a goalie in trade or UFA. No choice. Can't just bet on Dobes.I don't buy these goalie rumors Hughes just re-upped all the 3 goalies for 2 years and we have Dobes already who is just behind Levi stats wise in the ncaa.
The standings are tight by design that leave the numbers of teams selling low so Kent will make out like a bandit again this year. Lfg
habsfan891
Registered User
Edmonton going to cheap themselves into another failed season, in other news water is wet
Last edited:
MarkovsKnee
Global Moderator
I don't think Pedneault has any sources, but conversation should change to other teams beside Edmonton anyways.
Buffalo needs help at LD, as do LAK. Both of whom have much stronger prospect systems and better draft pick depth than Edmonton.
You also have to think TB would be interested, especially with the extra year. We could help them by taking back Myers (RFA 2023). I don't see them sitting on their D as it is. They are far more willing to give value in trades if they are filling a hole (eg: Hagel).
Depending on where other teams sit by TD, there will be other interested parties.
Holland is a shit GM who's risk adverse at a time when Edmonton should be all in.
A prospect in net takes a while to develop. Levi is an interesting option and Hughes knows him quite well since he plays with his boys, I believe.
- Status
Ad
Upcoming events
-
-
-
-
-
GAME 3 - Drummondville Voltigeurs @ Victoriaville Tigres - Drummondville Voltigeurs leads series 2-0Wagers: 3Staked: $105.00Event closes- Updated: