He’s been better than McDavid and his offence has been more impactful towards wins. He’s the only one between the two that is even on the radar for the Hart.
McDavid is coming off a 6 game goalless streak, has had 4 pointless games, nearly half his point on the PP, 1st in secondary assists.
Matthews has 13 goals in 18 games. Points in 17 of 18 games. 6 game winners in their 14 wins. 1st in even strength goals, 2nd in even strength points, 2nd in goals created, and tied for 1st with McDavid for point shares. He’s also the better off puck player.