Mr Jiggyfly
Registered User
- Jan 29, 2004
- 34,377
- 19,422
For your first sentence: young people today haven't seen Gretzky or Mario play in his prime, yet no one would ever say that Crosby is better than 99 or 66. Of course they care more about Sid because they've seen him play and watched his highlights. But Sid's status as an all time great will never come close to Gretzky's. Not now, not in 50 years.
As for your 2nd sentence, I don't understand what it has to do with anything. In the grand scheme of thing, football did not lose a single fan when Manning retired or when Brady will retire. But that has no bearing on their GOAT status.
On the flip side hockey is a little different, the minute Sid and Geno leave the organization the attendance and TV viewership will decrease by a significant amount. The sell out streak will end that same season. Every fanbase has a lot of fair weather fans and they show up for 2 reasons. Star players and team success.
That’s because you aren’t following the discussion.
Another poster said the NFL will never be the same without Brady and I disagreed.
Once he retires, he will be recognized as the best ever, but very few fans will care enough to stop enjoying the game.
They will be focused on their own teams... probably glad he’s gone... and other stars like Mahomes and likely Lawrence will become the faces of the league.
In 10+ years, a new generation of fans won’t care about Brady and his legacy anymore than young fans today care about Montana, Elway and Aikman.
They will likely recognize how great Brady was, but very few will not enjoy the NFL because he retired ten years ago.