I have made a list of players that should get consideration to move up in the top-100. Most of these players get recognition in the All-Time draft top-100 (and that his including players like Kharlamov, Fetisov and Tretiak, that are ruled out in here).
Ed Belfour - certainly a chance, probably in the 75-100 range
Rob Blake - No
Martin Brodeur - Absolutely, probably in the 20s
Pavel Bure - maybe but would probably be in the 90-100 range
Sergei Fedorov - maybe but would probably be in the 90-100 range
Adam Foote - no way, not even if it was a Top 200, maybe a Top 300
Peter Forsberg - absolutely, probably around the 60s or 70s
Ron Francis - maybe but would probably be in the 90-100 range
Doug Gilmour - probably falls short, but it'll probably be close
Niklas Lidstrom - absolutely, and certainly in the top half, probably 30s or 40s
Al MacInnis - Yeah I think so, around the 70s
Larry Murphy - No
Scott Niedermayer - Not quite, but a Stanley Cup this season will get him closer
Chris Pronger - Yes, probably around the 70s, and a Stanley Cup this season would help
Luc Robitaille - No, not quite
Brendan Shanahan - Close, but I think he'd fall short
Scott Stevens - Yes, probably in the 60s or 70s
Mats Sundin - No