- Jun 10, 2014
- 57,429
- 29,289
We’ve seen pretty hefty jumps in recent years.
Oilers jumped a fair bit to land McDavid. Us with Laine. Philly with Patrick. Rangers now with Lafreniere. Heiskanen to Dallas was a big lottery jump too IIRC.
I understand the purpose of the lottery but crap like that was/is happening far too often.
Over a large sample it will match the lottery ball odds. But in any one year, the worst odds could win.
Oilers finished the season in 3rd place from the bottom, jumped up 2 for McD. No big deal.
We were in 6th place when we jumped up to 2. Again, not all that much of a jump.
Philly was in 12th place and jumped to #2. That is pretty big. But if you don't want teams in 12th to jump up 10 spots, don't give them a lottery ticket.
Dallas was in 7th place and jumped to 3rd. You should probably expect a jump of that size most years. That year had that one plus the much bigger Philly jump.
Rangers getting Laf was a huge jump and that will happen occasionally.
The lottery is to discourage tanking. If you don't like the way some teams have jumped up, make some changes. But not the ones being made. Limit the lottery to 12 teams instead of 16. Readjust the odds so that those last 4 teams have an even lower chance of winning. Then be ready for the 12th place team to win it occasionally. Don't overreact to a small sample.