Bubba Thudd
is getting banned
I'm curious to know why you feel Paul Stastny, who would be coming up to unrestricted free agency for the first time, would be more likely to take a $2m+ paycut AAV in your scenario than O'Reilly to sign long-term in the $5m AAV range.
If this free agency has shown anything, it is that teams will overpay for guys they feel can scrape by in certain roles. A guy who is barely a top 4 defenseman will be paid like a very good #2/#3. A second line center will be paid like a good first line center. If we feel Staz is still a first line center with the right situation(see USA in World Championships), then I have no reason to believe he would come down that far.
Stastny, as a UFA over these past 24 hours or whatever, would have gotten $7m AAV or something silly. No doubt in my mind.
I think we could move Stastny, along with a draft pick(2014 1st or 2nd depending on the player) and maybe an Elliott or something, for a damn good defenseman. That would also shed us of Paul's $6.6m salary and allow us to allocate that for extensions elsewhere.
Just my two cents. I'll be awaiting the comments by people saying I am simply biased against Staz.
Why U hate Staz so much?
Seriously, though, I don't think he'll sign with us for anything less than 6M. It would be nice if he signed for 5-5.5, but I don't expect it. He'll get 7M in the UFA market next year, as long as he doesn't have an atrocious year.
I still say the best bet is to sign him, and trade him. Add the 2014 first round pick, and maybe McGinn to get a top-pairing D. I don't want to trade Elliott yet -- I'd rather him play in LEM, getting top-pairing minutes with Siemens.
I would like to get Hainsey -- or some upgrade on D -- in the meantime, on a short term contract. We rush our D prospects into the NHL, and they lose confidence. And then the fans lose confidence in them.
Add Hainsey, trade an extended Staz + 2014 first round pick, and McGinn (or Sgarbossa, if he'll get the deal done) for a top-pairing D. Then if we need to look for a 3rd line C, it shouldn't be too terribly hard to find.
I don't think ROR will be content on the 3rd line -- he's shown he's better than that. I hope he'll be content -- and prosper -- on the Wing, but time will tell. If not, we'll likely have to trade him at the deadline. I'd expect picks/prospects, though, cuz we'd be trading him to a contender who won't want to give up a good defender going into a playoff run.