Spezza and Sochi Olympics

WhiteLight*

Guest
Spezza's cute no look passes to the other team have surely been noticed.

Plus, as good as he is, he's never dominated a game the way a guy like Crosby or Stamkos can.

If he finds that next level, there won't be any questions about him being on the team.

He can play his way on, it's up to him.

No he can't. It's been decided. They won't take the chance that he has one of those games while wearing the Red Maple Leaf. No matter how well he plays, they won't take the chance.
 

Qward

Because! That's why!
Jul 23, 2010
18,941
5,906
Behind you, look out
you could say that for anyone, but yes somewhat agree with you. but who would replace them? Goatlending is very thin.

Yzerman will take more "vet" guys over people like Hall and Subban.



Stamkos/Crosby/Iginla
Nash/Giroux/Perry
Bergeron/Toews/Tavares
E.Staal/Thornton/Marleau


Keith/Weber
Letang/Doughty
Pietrangelo/Staal


Luongo
Price
Brodeur


Is the limit 21 players right now? I know they want to change it but what is it right now?
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
Not at all. Spezza is straight up a better player than Tavares. There are not more than 3 centres that I would put ahead of Spezza. In fact since Giroux plays the wing I would only put Stamkos and Crosby ahead of Spezza as Canadian centres.

People really don't give Spezza the respect he deserves. Alfredsson said he's our best defensive player for a reason. He has REALLY amped it up in his own end, he makes smarter decisions and his faceoffs are unreal. On top of this he carried a team of kids with Karlsson to the playoffs while going 6th overall in Hart voting and finishing 4th in scoring. Honestly that he gets overlooked so much is unreal. I doubt there are 5 centres in the world let alone that are Canadian that could have done what Spezza did last year.

My team?

James Neal - Sidney Crosby - Corey Perry
Martin St. Louis - Steven Stamkos - Claude Giroux
Rick Nash - Jason Spezza - John Tavares
Taylor Hall - Jonathan Toews - Jordan Eberle

Eric Staal, Jamie Benn

Shea Weber - Alex Petriangelo
Duncan Keith - Kris Letang
Marc-Edouard Vlasic - Drew Doughty

Mark Methot, Brent Seabrook

Carey Price
Roberto Luongo
Marc-Andre Fleury

Source? I just don't believe you at all.

Also, Methot. Jesus
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
Yzerman will take more "vet" guys over people like Hall and Subban.



Stamkos/Crosby/Iginla
Nash/Giroux/Perry
Bergeron/Toews/Tavares
E.Staal/Thornton/Marleau


Keith/Weber
Letang/Doughty
Pietrangelo/Staal


Luongo
Price
Brodeur


Is the limit 21 players right now? I know they want to change it but what is it right now?

well, it's 23 players. 13-7-3 or 12-8-3.

They probably will take more vets, doesn't mean they should
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
It was a quote... I thought he said "bestoffensive player" but everyone else heard "best defensive player"

Say it in Alfie's voice and it makes sense....

lol ok

doubt Alfie actually said defensive. would be very surprised

uhh what? JT has never been better than Spezza offensively, at best they're equal right now, and is not relied on defensively at all.

JT brings it when he plays for Canada. He brings it in big games. He's also more versatile and a better goal scorer.

Because of these things, they'll take Tavares over Spezza even if they're ''equal''. Tavares could easily be better next year too.
 

MiscBrah

Registered User
Mar 16, 2012
3,550
548
He's not good enough plain and simple. It's not like he was gonna show any progression this season from his previous play.




Staal - Crosby - Stamkos
Hall - Tavares - Eberle
Benn - Toews - Giroux
Staal - Bergeron - Seguin
Couture

Keith - Doughty
Pietrangelo - Weber
Staal - Letang
Subban

Price
Luongo
Fleury

Spezza is better than Tavares, Toews, and Bergeron. Actually a lot of your choices can be questioned...

Not at all. Spezza is straight up a better player than Tavares. There are not more than 3 centres that I would put ahead of Spezza. In fact since Giroux plays the wing I would only put Stamkos and Crosby ahead of Spezza as Canadian centres.

People really don't give Spezza the respect he deserves. Alfredsson said he's our best defensive player for a reason. He has REALLY amped it up in his own end, he makes smarter decisions and his faceoffs are unreal. On top of this he carried a team of kids with Karlsson to the playoffs while going 6th overall in Hart voting and finishing 4th in scoring. Honestly that he gets overlooked so much is unreal. I doubt there are 5 centres in the world let alone that are Canadian that could have done what Spezza did last year.

My team?

James Neal - Sidney Crosby - Corey Perry
Martin St. Louis - Steven Stamkos - Claude Giroux
Rick Nash - Jason Spezza - John Tavares
Taylor Hall - Jonathan Toews - Jordan Eberle

Eric Staal, Jamie Benn

Shea Weber - Alex Petriangelo
Duncan Keith - Kris Letang
Marc-Edouard Vlasic - Drew Doughty

Mark Methot, Brent Seabrook

Carey Price
Roberto Luongo
Marc-Andre Fleury

This.
 

MiscBrah

Registered User
Mar 16, 2012
3,550
548
I can't edit my posts but I meant to say

"You only think that because...
 

saskriders

Can't Hold Leads
Sep 11, 2010
25,065
1,607
Calgary
Does anyone remember what Bergeron's role was?

Wasn't it mainly as a faceoff specialist?

Bergeron is pretty much the only centre (who should even should be considered to be in the conversation) better at faceoffs than Spezza, but Spezza has much better offensive upside. Could he play a faceoff specialist role?
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
Only because he has a cup. Like I said earlier Spezza will never get the respect he deserves until he has a cup.

No, it's the similar offensive output + Selke defense.

It's coming up huge in big games.

It's the Conn Smythe Trophy + Stanley Cup.

Olympic Gold, WC Gold, WJC Gold, U-17 Gold.

Toews is a winner, and everything Spezza isn't (in a good way)

9 out of 10 experts heard "best defensive player", after hearing the replay.

experts on?

Spezza is so far from being the best defensive player on the Sens. He's not even close to best defensive forward.
 

MiscBrah

Registered User
Mar 16, 2012
3,550
548
No, it's the similar offensive output + Selke defense.

It's coming up huge in big games.

It's the Conn Smythe Trophy + Stanley Cup.

Olympic Gold, WC Gold, WJC Gold, U-17 Gold.

Toews is a winner, and everything Spezza isn't (in a good way)



experts on?

Spezza is so far from being the best defensive player on the Sens. He's not even close to best defensive forward.

***** I forgot you have blinders on when talking about Spezza. Spezza is over a PPG player over twice the sample of Toews and he's not even a PPG player.

I guess it's fine to play on loaded teams and then claim that as to why you are so good?

Brb Spezza won the Spengler
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
Mandy might be the first person to make me use the ignore feature on any website I've ever been to. It really is unreal the ignorance and other things I can't say for fear of bannination.
 

HavlatMach9

streamable 3rah1
Mar 17, 2011
13,445
394
Ottawa
Mandy might be the first person to make me use the ignore feature on any website I've ever been to. It really is unreal the ignorance and other things I can't say for fear of bannination.
In his/her defense, he/she uses statistics and data to argue points, even if the conclusions are entirely wrong.
Like, the sky is blue, so a dragon comes out of it.
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
Toews is unquestionably better than Spezza.

In what way? He's really not at all. When Spezza played with players comparable to the players that Towes plays with now and has been playing with since before he won the cup Spezza was 100+ point pace player almost every year. Now his defensive game has really improved and he's also one of the better faceoff guys in the league.

Spezza is a way better playmaker, better at scoring goals, nearly as good at faceoffs, way better at carrying the puck but not quite as good defensively (and I would only say this because of reputation and physicality).

Spezza is closer defensively to Toews than Toews is offensively to Spezza.
 

1Gold Standard

Registered User
Jun 13, 2012
7,907
199
Yzerman will take more "vet" guys over people like Hall and Subban.



Stamkos/Crosby/Iginla
Nash/Giroux/Perry
Bergeron/Toews/Tavares
E.Staal/Thornton/Marleau


Keith/Weber
Letang/Doughty
Pietrangelo/Staal


Luongo
Price
Brodeur


Is the limit 21 players right now? I know they want to change it but what is it right now?


you mean repeat the mistakes of Gretzky in 2006 and the Torino games?
 

1Gold Standard

Registered User
Jun 13, 2012
7,907
199
In what way? He's really not at all. When Spezza played with players comparable to the players that Towes plays with now and has been playing with since before he won the cup Spezza was 100+ point pace player almost every year. Now his defensive game has really improved and he's also one of the better faceoff guys in the league.

Spezza is a way better playmaker, better at scoring goals, nearly as good at faceoffs, way better at carrying the puck but not quite as good defensively (and I would only say this because of reputation and physicality).

Spezza is closer defensively to Toews than Toews is offensively to Spezza.

I'd have to say Towes over Spezza each and everytime 10 times out of 10.

And your earlier selection of Methot on d (even if it is as an injury replacement) Not a chance! I wouldn't watch that fiasco if that's the way Hockey Canada wants to go.
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
***** I forgot you have blinders on when talking about Spezza. Spezza is over a PPG player over twice the sample of Toews and he's not even a PPG player.

I guess it's fine to play on loaded teams and then claim that as to why you are so good?

Brb Spezza won the Spengler

When it matters (playoffs and international tournaments), Toews is every bit as good offensively as Spezza. If not better (I think he is).

Toews has also been quite near ppg in the regular season... You know how Yzerman sacrificed offense for defense? That's Toews.

And then ramps it up to another level at crunch time.

Toews is a shutdown centre also. You know the Staal, Bergeron, Kesler types? Toews fits right in there.


That's the difference between the 2 players... Take that epic Toews shootout... Spezza doesn't do things like that. Toews has the it factor.

wit. Whatever it takes. Toews has it in spades. Spezza, not so much.
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
In what way? He's really not at all. When Spezza played with players comparable to the players that Towes plays with now and has been playing with since before he won the cup Spezza was 100+ point pace player almost every year. Now his defensive game has really improved and he's also one of the better faceoff guys in the league.

Spezza is a way better playmaker, better at scoring goals, nearly as good at faceoffs, way better at carrying the puck but not quite as good defensively (and I would only say this because of reputation and physicality).

Spezza is closer defensively to Toews than Toews is offensively to Spezza.

See above.

Also, Toews is a better goal scorer.

Also, sorry, but you're clueless if you think Spezza is anywhere near Toews defensively. Not just in the defensive zone, but in terms of being responsible all over the ice (turnovers and proper positioning).

Toews never had linemates as good as Alfredsson and Heatley. Not even close. Spezza scored more because of that and because scoring was just higher in general... Regular Season scoring also doesn't mean he'll produce more in the Olympics either obviously
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad