SinfulCobraZ GM Game Discussion Pt. 2

[Top 6 Spaling]

I don't really factor in chemistry that much because you never really know on paper. The only thing I will say is if there is a D pairing of like Green-Goligoski I'll be like "Woah, no defense there", but I don't even try to guess at chemistry.

Experience helps some, but not as big of a deal to me.

 

[The Produce Man]

No its 8-6. Still time to catch up and win.

I take no shame in coming up short here. Give the people what they want!

 

[Top 6 Spaling]

I take no shame in coming up short here. Give the people what they want!

We want you to rebuild from now on....

 

[AccuracyFive]

Personnally I dont think it's stupid per se, but I think people put too much emphasis on this. 100 points players are better and will most likely outperform 50 points players, experience or not.

And in this particular case the experience thing is exagerrated, both teams have about the same amount of players who were SC finalists or winners at some point in their career, and both also have players with barely any PO experience.

Exactly. No offense whatsoever to Produce but his top 2 centers would by my 3rd and 4th line centers. This is the most important forward position. I've got Gaborik and Nash to match up with Parise and Perry.

Doughty + Edler + Green + McDonagh. Thats four ELITE #1 defenseman.

Produce has got one of the best teams in this game no doubt and I voted him Division Winner in the standings and it makes sense that they could win this series, I am not saying that his team sucks but I dont like that people are voting against me because I dont have experienced players.

 

[AccuracyFive]

I take no shame in coming up short here. Give the people what they want!

No man. Sorry I want to win this fair and square. Not by you giving up. The Great Produce never gives up!

 

[ECWHSWI]

I don't really factor in chemistry that much because you never really know on paper. The only thing I will say is if there is a D pairing of like Green-Goligoski I'll be like "Woah, no defense there", but I don't even try to guess at chemistry.

Experience helps some, but not as big of a deal to me.

Agreed, I take experience into consideration when it's somewhat players of the same level, ex: two PPG players, the one with more experience have an edge IMO... but of both players arent of the same calibre, experience doesnt matter, at all.

 

[The Produce Man]

We want you to rebuild from now on....

After next game, I will.

But now I'm out for blood

 

[AccuracyFive]

After next game, I will.

But now I'm out for blood

Come on guys, we need more votes! Lets get it over with and start the next game!

 

[Top 6 Spaling]

Exactly. No offense whatsoever to Produce but his top 2 centers would by my 3rd and 4th line centers. This is the most important forward position. I've got Gaborik and Nash to match up with Parise and Perry.

Doughty + Edler + Green + McDonagh. Thats four ELITE #1 defenseman.

Produce has got one of the best teams in this game no doubt and I voted him Division Winner in the standings and it makes sense that they could win this series, I am not saying that his team sucks but I dont like that people are voting against me because I dont have experienced players.

I agree with everything in this post except for 2 things.

1. Gabby and Nash are close to Parise and Perry, but not quite there.

2. Mike Green is a #2/#3 defenseman. The term "elite #1" should never be used near this name.

That said, still voted for you

 

[HankTheTankYoLo]

is this game ended or what?

i say.. give it 1 more hour. then we see who have most votes?

 

[Top 6 Spaling]

After next game, I will.

But now I'm out for blood

Haven't you won enough?

 

[donghabs98]

Game thread will be up later tonight between 7:30-9pm EST

 

[ECWHSWI]

Exactly. No offense whatsoever to Produce but his top 2 centers would by my 3rd and 4th line centers. This is the most important forward position. I've got Gaborik and Nash to match up with Parise and Perry.

Doughty + Edler + Green + McDonagh. Thats four ELITE #1 defenseman.

Produce has got one of the best teams in this game no doubt and I voted him Division Winner in the standings and it makes sense that they could win this series, I am not saying that his team sucks but I dont like that people are voting against me because I dont have experienced players.

cup winner and cup finalist right there... and a C. Smythe winner in net... so, experience ? meh

 

[AccuracyFive]

is this game ended or what?

i say.. give it 1 more hour. then we see who have most votes?

No...Its until 19 votes, 10 PM or when I or Produce are mathematically eliminated. Currently its 8-6.

 

[The Produce Man]

Exactly. No offense whatsoever to Produce but his top 2 centers would by my 3rd and 4th line centers. This is the most important forward position. I've got Gaborik and Nash to match up with Parise and Perry.

Doughty + Edler + Green + McDonagh. Thats four ELITE #1 defenseman.

Produce has got one of the best teams in this game no doubt and I voted him Division Winner in the standings and it makes sense that they could win this series, I am not saying that his team sucks but I dont like that people are voting against me because I dont have experienced players.

I think in terms of pure DEFENSE, my team is better. Edler and Green wander a lot, leaves them out of position. Not saying they are bad, they are terrific 2-way guys so they are expected to chip in. But if I need to prevent a goal from going in, I'd take my D. And this team's bottom 6 is probably the best bottom 6 I have ever had.

 

[Top 6 Spaling]

Game thread will be up later tonight between 7:30-9pm EST

Is there any way you can post a list of which GM is with which team earlier than that so we can start talking trades? If not, it's fine, I can wait a few more hours.

 

[AccuracyFive]

I think in terms of pure DEFENSE, my team is better. Edler and Green wander a lot, leaves them out of position. Not saying they are bad, they are terrific 2-way guys so they are expected to chip in. But if I need to prevent a goal from going in, I'd take my D. And this team's bottom 6 is probably the best bottom 6 I have ever had.

Again, I am not saying your team is bad. Its probably one of the best in this game. However, in all honesty, if your team could afford Doughty, Edler, Green, and McDonagh and have Quick in net along iwth Kopitar and Thornton as your #1 and #2 centers and have two elite first line wingers in Nash and Gaborik, I am sure you would take that.

 

[The Produce Man]

Again, I am not saying your team is bad. Its probably one of the best in this game. However, in all honesty, if your team could afford Doughty, Edler, Green, and McDonagh and have Quick in net along iwth Kopitar and Thornton as your #1 and #2 centers and have two elite first line wingers in Nash and Gaborik, I am sure you would take that.

No doubt, I never said anything to the contrary.

 

[AccuracyFive]

No doubt, I never said anything to the contrary.

Anyway, point is:

This would be a hell of a match up in real life.

 

[HankTheTankYoLo]

Is there any way you can post a list of which GM is with which team earlier than that so we can start talking trades? If not, it's fine, I can wait a few more hours.

yes that would be nice

 

[Top 6 Spaling]

Anyway, point is:

This would be a hell of a match up in real life.

I feel that way about every cup final. All I can do is think "Damn, can you imagine a real series between these two?"

 

[ECWHSWI]

difference is on the wings

2nd line wingers
- Moulson : 69 pts last year
- Ryder : 62 pts last year (and he's a cup winner).

on the other side :
- Parize (I think everyone know who he is, no need for presentation)
- Stalberg...

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

Wait, what is going on? Who won?

 

[The Produce Man]

Well, I think everyone who was going to vote, has.

Win the Stanley Cup!!

 

[ECWHSWI]

Well, I think everyone who was going to vote, has.

Win the Stanley Cup!!

depends who hasnt voted yet