Proposal: Seth Jones for M. Marner

[stewpac]

No way does CbJ trade Jones for Marner
Maple Leafs would be stupid to turn down that trade if offered

I would never do this deal. NEVER!!!

 

[Sidney the Kidney]

We're all arguing with a poster who's HF account is barley a month old and at least half their total posts are arguing ridiculously indefensible points of view in this thread. I'd bet money that this is someone's second account used to just "stir the pot" so to speak

@Viqsi is probably bored and decided to make a second account to argue with.

 

[Jerkbait]

Can't believe someone even mentioned Yandle in this thread as an attempt to discredit Jones. Some of you have lost your damn minds.

Yandle has more points than jones that was the fact .

 

[Jerkbait]

You've spent far too much time stat watching if you believe Carlson, Karlsson, Burns are better than Jones.

.
Not just about stats but about intangibles. Hedman Carlson burns doughty alex Piet chabot all have more value than jones.....those types would fetch a 22 year old 100 point winger ..even that is far fetched . You guys think jones is going to win the norris or something. He wouldnt even be best D man on Toronto.

 

[WhiskeyYerTheDevils]

.
Not just about stats but about intangibles. Hedman Carlson burns doughty alex Piet chabot all have more value than jones.....those types would fetch a 22 year old 100 point winger ..even that is far fetched . You guys think jones is going to win the norris or something. He wouldnt even be best D man on Toronto.

When did Marner score 100 points in a season?

 

[PWJunior]

When did Marner score 100 points in a season?

In that poster's alternate universe where Jones wouldn't be Toronto's best d-man. Marner is also 7 feet tall and shoots fire from his eyes and shoots bolts of lightning from his arse there...

 

[Viqsi]

@Viqsi is probably bored and decided to make a second account to argue with.

Please. I could make a much better troll than that.

 

[Starat327]

Please. I could make a much better troll than that.

You sure, this ones awfully persistent and has dragged this dead horse out for 11 pages.

 

[Viqsi]

You sure, this ones awfully persistent and has dragged this dead horse out for 11 pages.

Fair point. I just prefer to start out subtle before descending into the outright insanity.

 

[Kamiccolo]

Every single thread about the Leafs F

"Marner is the best player on the Leafs and the others are over rated. Turned JT into a 47 goal scorer"

Every thread involving trading Marner

"LOL no. That contract, blah blah".

Pick a side I guess is my point.

 

[KingDeathMetal]

There is no universe where a young kid who is primed to average 90-100 pts per year is less valuable than a player who is good for 40-50 pts, maybe 60 if you're lucky. I don't care that he's a top five d-man.

It's not a crazy deal, but CBJ is definitely adding to Jones if they want Marner, HFBoards hive mind be damned.

 

[WildWolfdog]

The answer to every Jones proposal is always no. Whomever, whatever, whenever, forever. Always no.

Leaf fan here, and I actually agree with this lol.

Unless it's an obvious franchise C - in which case it wouldn't make sense for the other side.

So yeah, if Jones leaves it would only be in FA I don't see him ever getting traded.

 

[voxel]

Columbus declines. They are actually AHEAD of the Leafs in the standings with a ton of cap space to acquire a forward if they wanted to.

 

[LeafsNation75]

Every single thread about the Leafs F

"Marner is the best player on the Leafs and the others are over rated. Turned JT into a 47 goal scorer"

Every thread involving trading Marner

"LOL no. That contract, blah blah".

Pick a side I guess is my point.

That reminds me of those who said Auston Matthews is nothing but a player who couldn't get at least 70 points, however let's also hope Arizona signs him to a huge offer sheet if becomes an RFA.

 

[Kamiccolo]

That reminds me of those who said Auston Matthews is nothing but a player who couldn't get at least 70 points, however let's also hope Arizona signs him to a huge offer sheet if becomes an RFA.

Yep.

"Should Arizone do 15m x 4 years??"

Leafs get less money for more term

"What an awful deal"

 

[LeafsNation75]

Yep.

"Should Arizone do 15m x 4 years??"

Leafs get less money for more term

"What an awful deal"

Here is one of those threads if you want a good laugh.

Proposal: - Matthews Offer Sheet from Arizona?

 

[Kamiccolo]

Here is one of those threads if you want a good laugh.

Proposal: - Matthews Offer Sheet from Arizona?

Yeah he's an over rated bum until there is a chance he leaves the team. Same story the entire time I've been on this site.

 

[shortfuze]

Every single thread about the Leafs F

"Marner is the best player on the Leafs and the others are over rated. Turned JT into a 47 goal scorer"

Every thread involving trading Marner

"LOL no. That contract, blah blah".

Pick a side I guess is my point.

You done whining? Victims complex much

 

[glenngineer]

The answer to every Jones proposal is always no. Whomever, whatever, whenever, forever. Always no.

McDavid?

 

[shortfuze]

There is no universe where a young kid who is primed to average 90-100 pts per year is less valuable than a player who is good for 40-50 pts, maybe 60 if you're lucky. I don't care that he's a top five d-man.

It's not a crazy deal, but CBJ is definitely adding to Jones if they want Marner, HFBoards hive mind be damned.

So let’s say that this top 5 dman gets 60 points. You would trade him for Marner and vice versa. I’d definitely trade Marner for a top 5 D that is getting 60 points a season. I’d probably pack his bags to.

 

[Viqsi]

McDavid?

Covered earlier in the thread.

 

[Jerkbait]

There is no universe where a young kid who is primed to average 90-100 pts per year is less valuable than a player who is good for 40-50 pts, maybe 60 if you're lucky. I don't care that he's a top five d-man.

It's not a crazy deal, but CBJ is definitely adding to Jones if they want Marner, HFBoards hive mind be damned.

Compelty agree. Jackets would add but leafs would not make this deal. If jones was 60 to 70 points...hmmm a bit different

 

[GOilers88]

When was the last time a prime #1 defenseman with term was traded for a winger of any calibre straight up, let alone adding to do it?

Honest question.

 

[Jerkbait]

When did Marner score 100 points in a season?

Marner had 94 last year. Scoring well over a point per game pace this year. Would have made 100 if not for injury He will be a 90 to 110 point guy for the next 10 years barring no injury. Finished with more points than Tavares and matthews. And only 22.. and signed!!!!and you think leafs ship him to jackets for Jones??? Nylander yes..marner NO. Jones a great d man but it would take more to pry marner out of leaf town.

 

[GOilers88]

Compelty agree. Jackets would add but leafs would not make this deal. If jones was 60 to 70 points...hmmm a bit different

Since Marner and 94 points equates to a 90-100 point player, shouldn't Jones and 57 points equate to at least a 60 point player?