He was this good in New York and was one of the best D in the league back then. His last series against Montreal? He shut down their top players and posted 10 points in 6 games.
Last edited:
Player Discussion: Ryan McDonagh
- Thread starter LightningStrikes
- Start date
He was this good in New York and was one of the best D in the league back then. His last series against Montreal? He shut down their top players and posted 10 points in 6 games.
The Gongshow
Fire JBB
People have mentioned concern of him declining, but we have to remember we still have Heddy as our true #1.
We've been giving McDonagh the tougher matchups and minutes to help save/keep Hedman rested and fresh for the playoffs. But we can also start to switch that around to keep McDonagh's minutes down to the 16-18 mark as well.
I've liked what the couching staff has done with how they've handled Hedman-McD-Serg minutes
We've been giving McDonagh the tougher matchups and minutes to help save/keep Hedman rested and fresh for the playoffs. But we can also start to switch that around to keep McDonagh's minutes down to the 16-18 mark as well.
I've liked what the couching staff has done with how they've handled Hedman-McD-Serg minutes
DrMartinVanNostrand
Kramerica Industries
I have no reason to think McDonagh won't be worth his salary during the rest of his time with a NTC. Defensemen can, and often do, follow different aging curves than forwards. You can't put a price on having a pairing like him and Cernak in the playoffs. Genuine shutdown pairing. Think this postseason has confirmed that there's no way this organization leaves him exposed.
The Gongshow
Fire JBB
I think people just don't want a Seabrook situation. I can't see McDonagh falling off a cliff that hard.
The Gongshow
Fire JBB
The guy is a playoff warrior. He's also paired with a stud in Cernak, who might not get as much credit. Might help with any decline as well, but I seriously don't see any decline for another 2-3 years.
It'll take an injury to slow him down, but I think the recovery play we seen him make on Caufield last night doesn't happen in a few years. A lot of hard miles on that body already.
The Gongshow
Fire JBB
Stormbreaker
Registered User
- Apr 2, 2012
- 16,844
- 9,950
McD having his own boat parade
DaBolts
Stanley Cup Boat Parades ROCK
- Feb 3, 2015
- 15,131
- 10,775
I will die laughing if that's at the same lake as Jim Rome's summer home. He'll talk about this for a month. Way to go MacDaddy, can't wait to see you back on the ice. Enjoy the celebration!
Stormbreaker
Registered User
- Apr 2, 2012
- 16,844
- 9,950
Stormbreaker
Registered User
- Apr 2, 2012
- 16,844
- 9,950
Stammertime91
TBL: TEAM OF THE CENTURY
Imagine if he would have clipped that ceiling fan with the cup. Main boards would be raging.
The Gongshow
Fire JBB
CupsOverCash
Registered User
- Jun 16, 2009
- 16,396
- 7,126
Confirmed Trade: - [TBL/NYR] R. McDonagh, J. Miller for V. Namestnikov, B. Howden, L. Hajek, 2018 1st, c. 1st/2nd
This is a classic read! The thread before the trade happened was great too. Alots happened since then but is great to look back on.
This is a classic read! The thread before the trade happened was great too. Alots happened since then but is great to look back on.
LightningStrikes
Champa Bay Lightning
- Nov 24, 2009
- 26,259
- 10,126
Dude, for a second there my heart stopped and I thought we have traded Big Mac.
HanTykje
Registered User
Is he worth keeping? Will he able to play 70/82 games in a season (not with playoffs) Since 2017 he have about average 50 games a season, that cant be good enough?
- Jan 23, 2017
- 19,512
- 26,956
Well that's kinda been because of Covid... Since he got here he's only missed 29 games over ~4 years.
His contract will probably look really ugly in the later years, but given how good he is now (see: last playoffs) we're 100% better off keeping him.
The Macho King
Back* to Back** World Champion
- Jun 22, 2011
- 48,805
- 29,340
I also don't necessarily think the contract will look "ugly". I don't think he's a guy who's going to fall off a cliff, but rather have like a steady decline (more of a Ryan Suter-type). But I don't think we're going to be contenders that last year or two anyway.
DrMartinVanNostrand
Kramerica Industries
Pretty much how I would see it as well. Four years left on his contract after this year and he'll be 36 when the contract ends, coincidentally enough the same age Suter was when he was bought out last year. McD's always been an excellent skater, which should help him. I'm sure he'll still be perfectly useful for at least the next two seasons, which is during our contention window anyway. And after that his contract will be down to only 1-2 years anyway at which point it's not too big of an anchor anymore anyway just due to lack of remaining term.
He's got an NTC anyway so while we're still Cup contenders he's probably not too big on being traded right now. Maybe towards the end of the contract if we're struggling and there's someone out there interested. Whatever. Years down the road, so not a bridge we're gonna be crossing anytime soon anyway.
Stammertime91
TBL: TEAM OF THE CENTURY
Mcdonagh has shown no regression since he's been here. Game has looked the same and his positioning covers for everything. The contract will age well. Look at all these garbage contracts for "elite" defenseman. Lol.
Go look at the assists this guy got last postseason. Off the top of my head, from memory (cause he was a gamebreaker for both offense and defense)
Game 1 against FL, assisted on Points GWG breakaway
Game 7 assist on the ECF series clinching goal
Assist on the Coleman diving goal
Assist on the Cup clinching goal (credit to Savard too)
I've forgotten the others at the moment but he had 5-7 plays where his transition left an absolutely incredible mark on the series. He's calm and poised in a way even Hedman isn't.
Go look at the assists this guy got last postseason. Off the top of my head, from memory (cause he was a gamebreaker for both offense and defense)
Game 1 against FL, assisted on Points GWG breakaway
Game 7 assist on the ECF series clinching goal
Assist on the Coleman diving goal
Assist on the Cup clinching goal (credit to Savard too)
I've forgotten the others at the moment but he had 5-7 plays where his transition left an absolutely incredible mark on the series. He's calm and poised in a way even Hedman isn't.
Last post-season really showed that he's still a #1 when required. Hedman was injured, so McDonagh stepped up. Earned the entire contract in four rounds, IMO.
LightningStrikes
Champa Bay Lightning
- Nov 24, 2009
- 26,259
- 10,126
