I disagree.
But Beaulieu did step up a couple of times and I give him credit for that.
I thought Poolman was our best player at times in the play in. Made some great plays that no one finished for him. But he is still a 3rd pair Dman.
I don't think Beaulieu is as food defensively as Merrill is. Neither of them is any good offensively. I'm not going to assume that either Samberg or Heinola is ready for any more than 3rd pair duty to start the season. How quickly they might be ready to move up is anybody's guess.
Agree that the right side is more of a priority. But we need somebody on the left side in case neither Samberg nor Heinola is NHL ready yet. Even 3rd pair is a big step up from where they are now. In that case we have JMo, Merrill, Beaulieu on the left. All we have for sure right now is Morrissey and Dahlstrom.
Sign DeMelo, sign Merrill, everything is covered. If the opportunity is there we might include Pionk in a trade for a better RD than DeMelo. If that doesn't come along, we go with DeMelo, Pionk, Poolman.
I think Poolman was pretty good too, he brought some offensive jump out of that 3rd pairing. Beaulieu was the only plus player we had though on defense, in the playins, though that plus was negated by quite a few goals on the PK. I just don't see it with Merrill, for reference he was behind Sbisa on the Golden Knights run for the Stanley Cup.
I'm looking at the left side as being
1. Morrissey
2. Samberg
3. Beaulieu
4. Heinola
5. Dahlstrom
6. Chisholm
7. Stanley
Plus you have Niku in the mix. That's alot of LD, 3 top 4 quality ones available. Dahlstrom could be a 12 minute a night 3LD if called upon. Stanley could jump him this season. Chisholm will get the development season in the minors.
The right side going into this offseason is
1. Pionk
2. Poolman
3. Niku
4. Kovacevic
5. Gawanke
6. Green
I think the Jets are going to want to upgrade on De Melo. I think it's probable we sign Hamonic, but that is probably as a better defensive option than Poolman, in a shut down physical pairing, other than Morrissey's, and somebody in that 1RD position. It could just be Hamonic instead of De Melo, but I'm not sure that's a strong enough d corps. We'd be counting on 2018-19 Hamonic and not last year's. If we did go that way there's alot more money to invest in a top 6 centre.