You make it sound like he has arrived which he has not. 20+ defensemen ahead of him in points last He is a stud considering age but has a long way ahead of him and the journey to become a superstar d is a uncertain one and player development is not linear. I think its a good thing fans of other teams are holding him under a microscope.
About the goal - it was nice.
Yeah 20 dman were ahead of him in points but lets see.
Was 18 years old. Virtually no dmen even play a full season at age 18 let alone even come close to what Dahlin produced.
Erik Karlsson - Didn't play in his D+1. Scored 26 in 60 in D+2 at age 19.
Drew Doughty - Turned 19 2 months into his D+1 season. Scored 27 points
Seth Jones - Turned 19 before the season even started in his D+1. Scored 25. Didn't hit 40 until his D+4.
Victor Hedman - Turned 19 2 months into his D+1. Didn't eclipse 26 points until his D+5.
Alex Pietrangelo - Didn't score 40+ until D+3.
John Carlson - D+7 he hits his first 40 point season.
PK Subban - D+7 finally hits 40.
I can just go on and on. What Dahlin did is literally something unseen in nearly 40 YEARS. Before haters try to bring up the whole "OH HES A DMAN POINTZZZ " ill cut that shit off right there. You are not an elite franchise dman unless you excel at both ends. Dahlins D game is great for a 19 year old and is just as good if not better as all of those listed above were at his age, hell even older for those guys. He is generational and it is not even debatable.
Since 2005 there are 2 players drafted who can be considered better prospects/players and that is Sidney Crosby and Connor McDavid. He is a whole tier ahead of the next group of 1OAs such as Matthews, Stamkos, Hall, Kane, Tavares etc. There are 4 generational talents drafted in the last 25 years. Ovechkin (arguably best goal scorer in league history), Crosby (best player seen since 66 and 99), McDavid (best player since Crosby) and then Dahlin (2nd most productive 18 year old dman in the 100 year history of the NHL)
That goal he scored last night was a superstars goal. It happened so fast and with how he broke in alone I was assuming it was a left handed shot forward like Skinner or VO breaking in until I realized the gazelle powering to the goal was way to big to be one of those 2.
Like how scouts said Dahlin goes #1 even if he switched to forward before the draft its absolutely true. The Lidstrom comparisons are spot on. To be honest if winning McDavid in 2015 meant getting Svechnikov or Brady Tkachuk over Dahlin 3 years later then I am glad how things turned out.
Eichel + Dahlin > McDavid + Svechnikov/Tkachuk/Kotkaniemi
90 point franchise C + superstar dman > 110 point superstar C + ~70 point star first liner.