Pick the 3 Hart finalists

[wetcoast]

McDavid
Matthews
Marchand

McDavid is the obvious choice here but I took out Mathews and put in Crosby.

There are probably 5 or 6 guys with legit arguments for the 2 and 3 spots, including Leon Drasaital.

 

[GMofOilers]

McDavid, McKinnon, Crosby

Sorry Matthew doesnt deserve to be in the top 3. Doesnt matter how many goals, 0.5A/G is a embarrassing low number to be taken seriously esp when you add it all together and your not even in the top5 for overall scoring. The only trophy he deserves is the Rocket. Marner should get more votest for the Hart then Matthews, hes the driver on the team.

 

[amnesiac]

McDavid, McKinnon, Crosby

Sorry Matthew doesnt deserve to be in the top 3. Doesnt matter how many goals, 0.5A/G is a embarrassing low number to be taken seriously esp when you add it all together and your not even in the top5 for overall scoring. The only trophy he deserves is the Rocket. Marner should get more votest for the Hart then Matthews, hes the driver on the team.

41 assists in a full season is "embarrassing" now apparently..... gimme a break, man. The guy wouldve had 60+ goals.

 

[GlitchMarner]

Not sure why I keep seeing Crosby. He was pretty mediocre 5on5 this year. Feasted on the empty net without Empty net points he isn't even PPG.

13th among C's and 37th among forwards in 5on5 production

Seriously? Damn... how many EN points did he have exactly?

 

[GMofOilers]

41 assists in a season is "embarrassing" now apparently..... gimme a break, man.

Sure is for a top player, and hes never hit that number before.

Marner is the driver/MVP of the Leafs.

 

[GlitchMarner]

McDavid

Matthews

Draisaitl

 

[amnesiac]

Sure is for a top player, and hes never hit that number before.

Marner is the driver/MVP of the Leafs.

so a player with say 60G 40A isnt all that good..... gotcha. You know how embarrassing a comment that is?

Never stop, HF. Classic.

 

[Perfect_Drug]

McDavid
Matthews
Crosby


Sad part about Matthews insane season is any other year in the past 10, he would be unanimous for the Hart.

 

[Fatass]

McDavid wins
Barkov second
Mackinnon third

 

[GMofOilers]

so a player with say 60G 40A isnt all that good..... gotcha.

Never stop, HF. Classic.

Show me where I said sucks?

 

[explore]

This is one of those years where the separation between the eventual winner and the finalists is really far

The finalists might as well be:

McDavid

McDavid

McDavid

 

[Namikaze Minato]

Show me where I said sucks?

Show me where he said you said he sucks?

 

[amnesiac]

Show me where I said sucks?

isnt all that good.

You voted MacKinnon, hes got a 9.7 shot% this year on a stacked team.

 

[GMofOilers]

Show me where he said you said he sucks?

Edit is a wonderful option. He said it.

 

[GMofOilers]

isnt all that good.

You voted MacKinnon, hes got a 9.7 shot% this year on a stacked team.

Lead his team to the PC.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

McDavid, McKinnon, Crosby

Sorry Matthew doesnt deserve to be in the top 3. Doesnt matter how many goals, 0.5A/G is a embarrassing low number to be taken seriously esp when you add it all together and your not even in the top5 for overall scoring. The only trophy he deserves is the Rocket. Marner should get more votest for the Hart then Matthews, hes the driver on the team.

He was in the top 5 for overall scoring, tied with Rantanen and Kane. Mackinnon, who you voted for, is 8th overall for scoring.

How do you justify this?


Edit: and Crosby is 10th, who you also voted for.

 

[amnesiac]

Lead his team to the PC.

Thats your logic? a team wins the Presidents Trophy last I checked. He sure as hell didnt do it alone. The Hart is an individual award.

and again, to you having a 60G 40A season isnt all the good. Justify that. Cus you look damn foolish right now.

 

[kevsh]

McDavid
MacKinnon
Matthews

 

[GMofOilers]

He was in the top 5 for overall scoring, tied with Rantanen and Kane. Mackinnon, who you voted for, is 8th overall for scoring.

How do you justify this?

MacKinnon lead his team to a PC, and is the driver of the team, not Rantanen
Marner is the driver of the Leafs, not Matthews.

Hell I think Drai is better then them all except McDavid, yet I dont put him in the top 3. Its not a favorite player trophy. Its most valuable to his team. MacKinnon and Marner are more valuable to their teams then Rantanen Matthews in my opinion, would love for someone to actually prove that wrong.......Ill wait instead of answering questions moving the goal posts every post.

 

[GMofOilers]

Thats your logic? a team wins the Presidents Trophy last I checked. He sure as hell didnt do it alone. The Hart is an individual award.

and again, to you having a 60G 40A season isnt all the good. Justify that. Cus you look damn foolish right now.

Marner is the driver of the Leafs. No?

 

[WetcoastOrca]

McDavid
Matthews
Draisaitl

 

[Namikaze Minato]

MacKinnon lead his team to a PC, and is the driver of the team, not Rantanen
Marner is the driver of the Leafs, not Matthews.

Hell I think Drai is better then them all except McDavid, yet I dont put him in the top 3. Its not a favorite player trophy. Its most valuable to his team. MacKinnon and Marner are more valuable to their teams then Rantanen Matthews in my opinion, would love for someone to actually prove that wrong.......Ill wait instead of answering questions moving the goal posts every post.

So you want somebody to use facts to change your opinion, of which you have not provided any facts to prove.

Why does your opinion get presented as fact but mine is something that needs to be proven to you?

 

[GMofOilers]

So you want somebody to use facts to change your opinion, of which you have not provided any facts to prove.

Why does your opinion get presented as fact but mine is something that needs to be proven to you?

So you think Matthews is more valuable to his team the Marner? I dont, its close, really close and for that, I think it takes away from a top3 hart voting.

 

[amnesiac]

Marner is the driver of the Leafs. No?

thats your opinion. It sure as hell isnt the consensus.... Theyre both elite players much like EDM and COL's duos. All I Know is Matthews just had the best goalscoring season since Ovi's 65, and was still on pace to have 104 pts!

I mean your 0.5A/game statement just made you lose all credibility alone. If you just value playmakers more than goalscorers, fine, but the guy was on pace for 65 goals and finish 5th in scoring. Apparently thats not Hart worthy.... right.

You could argue Rantanen was more valuable than MacK too for that matter.

 

[Namikaze Minato]

So you think Matthews is more valuable to his team the Marner? I dont, its close, really close and for that, I think it takes away from a top3 hart voting.

I do, as somebody who has watched nearly every game of both of their careers. They drive in different ways but Matthews is more valuable to me.