I will have little to zero interest to watch this team if Phaneuf returns with the C. They identified the wrong problem.
Babcock has worked magic with average D before. Phaneuf doesn't have the baggage Kessel has. He just needs support like Kronwall got with Dekeyser/Smith and Green now.
Keeping Phaneuf this year makes a hell of a lot more sense. This guy wants to prove he can be the guy to lead us through the rebuild.
I've got zero problems with Phaneuf for the next 3-4 years. He just shouldn't be our best D 2 years from now though.