Peter Chiarelli Appreciation Thread

[CantHaveTkachev]

That's because we had Hall+Ebs and a bunch of garbage surrounding them.



Hard to be good defensively as a forward when your whole defense is trash

hence why he traded Hall for a semblance of an NHL defense

 

[StevenF1919]

that's debatable, but what isn't is that our defense was a trainwreck...Hall was the price to pay in order to have an NHL defense

Tell Treliving that, because he paid a hell of a lot less for Hamilton and Hamonic.

 

[McDrai]

that's debatable, but what isn't is that our defense was a trainwreck...Hall was the price to pay in order to have an NHL defense

Then why did Calgary not have to give up any roster players for good nhl dmen such as Hamilton and Hamonic?

 

[MessierII]

Then why did Calgary not have to give up any roster players for good nhl dmen such as Hamilton and Hamonic?

Because Neely

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

Then why did Calgary not have to give up any roster players for good nhl dmen such as Hamilton and Hamonic?

Tell Treliving that, because he paid a hell of a lot less for Hamilton and Hamonic.

and they've been amazing with those 2 in the line-up!

Hamilton in particular has been a part of zero playoff wins!

#overratedefense

 

[StevenF1919]

and they've been amazing with those 2 in the line-up!

Hamilton in particular has been a part of zero playoff wins!

#overratedefense

 

[McDrai]

and they've been amazing with those 2 in the line-up!

Hamilton in particular has been a part of zero playoff wins!

#overratedefense

Like it or not, Hamilton/Hamonic and Hall would have done wonders for our team over Larsson and plug

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

whoa..barely over .500? look out!

btw...what Calgarys record last year after after 16 games with a healthy line-up and Hamilton there?

 

[booyakasha]

I'm worried about the return he'll get for RNH, and the contract he will give Maroon.

 

[Canovin]

Like it or not, Hamilton/Hamonic and Hall would have done wonders for our team over Larsson and plug

16th + 33rd for Hamilton
RNH+Ebs for Larsson
Hall is still an Oilers
The defense is set
Oilers have 3 line drivers
McDavid, Drai and Hall run their own lines

 

[MessierII]

16th + 33rd for Hamilton
RNH+Ebs for Larsson
Hall is still an Oilers
The defense is set
Oilers have 3 line drivers
McDavid, Drai and Hall run their own lines

Boston turned down that deal. We literally offered that.

 

[McDrai]

16th + 33rd for Hamilton
RNH+Ebs for Larsson
Hall is still an Oilers
The defense is set
Oilers have 3 line drivers
McDavid, Drai and Hall run their own lines

If only we could go back in time lol

 

[StevenF1919]

whoa..barely over .500? look out!

btw...what Calgarys record last year after after 16 games with a healthy line-up and Hamilton there?

5 points ahead of us and they don't have the best player in the league on their team.

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

Like it or not, Hamilton/Hamonic and Hall would have done wonders for our team over Larsson and plug

and you're great a looking at hindsight trades

cause you were awfully quiet last year when Hall wasn't here and we started 7-1

 

[Canovin]

Boston turned down that deal. We literally offered that.

Wasn't the rumor was the Bruins turned down the offer because they heard that Chia was going to offersheet Hamilton?

 

[MessierII]

Wasn't the rumor was the Bruins turned down the offer because they heard that Chia was going to offersheet Hamilton?

Never heard that only that they wanted the picks + nurse from us.

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

5 points ahead of us and they don't have the best player in the league on their team.

and 74 games to play
74

 

[McDrai]

and you're great a looking at hindsight trades

cause you were awfully quiet last year when Hall wasn't here and we started 7-1

Could have been 8-0 instead of 7-1

 

[MessierII]

and 74 games to play
74

Nope can’t make up 5 points over that stretch. Can’t be done.

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

Nope can’t make up 5 points over that stretch. Can’t be done.

Good thing we have a bunch of easy games coming up...

 

[CantHaveTkachev]

16th + 33rd for Hamilton
RNH+Ebs for Larsson
Hall is still an Oilers
The defense is set
Oilers have 3 line drivers
McDavid, Drai and Hall run their own lines

why stop at these hindsight trades?
Oilers should've drafted Kucherov #1 in 2011, Lindholm #1 in 2012 then Ristolainen #8 in 2013

imagine our team then

 

[Drivesaitl]

and 74 games to play
74

And we already have 6 losses. We had 26 afairc last season.

Kings are already 10pts ahead. Only one team behind us, the NHL relegation team.

 

[Paralyzer]

Why am I not surprised people can't read in here and see this is an appreciation thread, not a shit on the person thread? Guess reading isn't a strong point...

 

[KeithIsActuallyBad]

Why am I not surprised people can't read in here and see this is an appreciation thread, not a **** on the person thread? Guess reading isn't a strong point...

Look at you showing all that appreciation.

I would appreciate if he'd improve the damn team like he should've months ago.

 

[Tyrolean]

Look at you showing all that appreciation.

I would appreciate if he'd improve the damn team like he should've months ago.