Dear God the roster is not that good. Including the top end of the roster. So you think that DOC, Puustinen, and Yager are the quality of players who put a 37-38 year old core over the top?
I said I'd keep those players, ideally I would move O'Connor since he likely won't do much for the Pens even with a new coach, he just needs a fresh start, the other 2 you mention - A new coach that will use them correctly, you're reading more into it than I stated, mate.
Let's get serious now. This thing is totally spent. There is not juice to wring out of this any more. Fire Sully with a new coach bump (right now, tomorrow) but barring that it is malfeasance to put off the rebuild any longer. No matter how many pet prospects from a bottom of the barrel minor league system you happen to like.
Fire Sully anyway because f him. But this is so stupid. We are done.
Fire Sully, yes. I don't think there's any moves Dubas can make that will rocket this team into some sort of contender this season.
You'd need to get a coach that will understand the top 6 and how to use a top 6 (Gallant is the name I mentioned because he's actually very good at this sort of thing, identifying how to utilize the top 9 to generate offense), then you need to make moves to at least make that top 9 start producing.
To make that happen? (this season)
First you need to drop Eller down to 4C where he anchors the 4th line as a solid pivot for that role, throw in Gruden and maybe rotate Hinostroza and someone else and roll with that, at least that saves cap.
Dubas would then need to add a 3C that can produce in a less restrictive role that Sullivan would have put them in, so really, any 3C currently in the league that is available will maybe actually work this time in that role. Now for this? I actually don't mind keeping O'Connor and Puljujarvi or Puustinen for as the usage is a huge factor, Sullivan has never understood any of that.
Top 6? Well - Guentzel, you either hang on to him and move him in the summer where the return won't be much but before the window they can talk to teams, if a team has the cap and wants to get him signed asap so they can make the next moves off that, sure maybe you wait - really bad risk though. Or you sign Guentzel to a crippling contract, because the max years are 8, there's no chance Guentzel is going for the bargain anyone here thinks. He's 30, just had a baby, he's on the verge of missing the playoffs twice if he stays under Sully. Or you deal him at the TDL and maybe target less of the multiple picks and talk to a team on Jake's list (the other teams excluded from his 12 team list) and aim for a young winger, a prospect, and a conditional pick that can be a first - based on his performance (takes them to the Conf finals is a 1st, they bounce in the 1st round it isn't, but if they sign him, it's a 1st). The latter I can deal with as it still gives this team hope under a new coach.
Malkin, Dubas can't f*** around here, either he finally look at providing him the proper support for wingers like they love to do for Sid and give Malkin that same respect or move Malkin to wing and pray a 2C that is having a down year is available and the team will take less to just remove the contract. The funny thing is I would love to see Granlund be back either with Geno as the C for Malkin or the 3rd line under a new coach and see him keep thriving just as a massive "See FSG, your f***ing boy was the problem."But MG isn't struggling, SJ will probably get something good for him at the TDL. Names aren't as important for the point I am trying to make here, but you get what I am getting at now?
For "fire Sully and do these things" it's a lot. You fire Sully now just to make as many moves as you can to situate yourself for an off-season with more cap space and maneuverability as well as add more draft picks to really make this the big draft to re-stock as much as possible so near the final year of Sid, Geno, Tang, they can start to push for a roster spot and have a chance at learning from some Pens legends.
They have 5 picks out of 7, they don't have their 1st, 3rd, and 5th and have two 7 rounders (2nd, 4th, 6th, and 7x2) - If Dubas is smart and sees his opportunity to really reshape the Penguins and get a quicker turn around, he fires Sullivan tomorrow morning and starts to move some pieces out and finish the season on a positive note with better performances and usage out of players because players LIKE Puustinen, Puljujarvi, Gruden, O'Connor, Joseph, etc all deserve to be coached by someone that will actively give them a chance to succeed in positions to succeed rather than punish them for not being grinder veterans. Then heading into the summer, he can move them if need be to just cull and look at Euro free agents to bring over etc.