So the Selke is basically the best defensive shutdown forward that can score and the Norris has become the same thing
several years ago i came to my own conclusion nhl needs to redefine all rewards (and rename them to make them relevant)
both forward and defense need a true 'defense' award
id let the top 50 scorers vote... criteria is who is the toughest player to score against... maybe let the 31 coaches vote too... who do you gameplan most for
call the trophys the bob gainey and the rod langway
then have offense awards not based on leading the scoring... but voted on who is the most intimidating player to stop... call it the pavel bure if you wish... the bobby orr for dmen...
names can be voted on by fans... but the awards deserve to be created
id go further... id do an award for most complete 3 zone player which basically replaces the selke... do it for dmen too
id replace the lady byng with a most respected award... voted by players to someone that sets example both for teammates as well as fans how to play pro...
can call it the steve yzerman maybe
dont get me wrong... i do feel bergeron is the best defensive forward in nhl over past 7-8 years... but im frustrated that you have to have minimum 50 points to even be nominated. let the players vote who frustrates them
(of course not alot of shadowing anymore with everyone playing more zone defense and sticking to coaching system)