Go check on the Panthers drafting history before Tallon came to manage the team.
Florida Panthers Draft History at hockeydb.com
There's been a huge change and getting some hits even on later picks. Taking Barkov also was not a terrible or insane move. It was well known that he's a great talent with size down the middle. Many people in Europe who saw him play thought he was the best player of the draft. Tallon had the balls to take the risk with someone who has to adapt to the small rink. Ultimately all picks fall to GM who takes the information from the scouts.
Player development is allright with proper talent. Barkov and Huberdeau are doing it right and Ekblad has fixed his downward trajectory. Matheson shows some brilliance at times. Trocheck has done great. Bjugstad is better and I trust points will come. The #1 line Florida currently has is one of the better lines in the league, that all is credit on Tallon.
You also have 2 division titles since he came over 2010 for teams that were not expected to compete on such a level.
There's plenty of good, he has a vision how to build the team and help to do it from within.
And I do have stuff to criticize on him as well. I just can't understand what happened with the team last off season when the first rebuild was put off track after some success. Now he's back to get some success.
I get it, it's sad that the team has not been able to get in or really find success in the playoffs. I am optimistic however that for some of the current players the 2015-16 playoff experience will help a lot in the not so distant future.
Management can't give in to a pressure and hit the panic button or it's always going to be a mess. Be careful what you wish for. The past cannot dictate the future here or you're always shackled by it. Do things right and with patience. Re-evaluate the current process after 19-20 or 20-21 as there is plenty of good coming up. The young guys are taking plenty of experience even from these losses that will carry to the future. Don't destroy the core or move the good prospects they have coming up right now, all they need is time. If you think time is not what you have then you have to re-evaluate the situation.