Proposal: Palmieri to Pittsburgh

[Unbiased Fan]

Nice list, remind me how many cups do all those players have? Dumo is a top pairing D man with a really good AAV. Palmieri is a nice RW but something tells me he is gone one way or another. Pens can get him for far less at the TDL but Shero will ask to much and hope someone meets that ask. I assure you it will never be Dumo.

Well Keith has 3

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Palmieri for Matt Murray

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

I know that Dumo is a good player but what good does listing Cup wins as it was some type of personal accomplishment?

 

[td_ice]

Makar is RHD.

Would rather have 28 year old prime Dumo, than several of the older guys on that list, Edler, Chara, Suter, Keith.

One dimensional offensive players, Yandle, Barrie, depends on what you need more for your team, offense or defensive player like Dumo.

Lindolm, Muzzin, Klefbom, Orlov? I would rather have Dumo. But ymmv.

 

[Gurglesons]

I know that Dumo is a good player but what good does listing Cup wins as it was some type of personal accomplishment?

Well, he was the # 1 D on one of those cup winners and carried a pairing with Ron Hainsey during that.

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

Well, he was the # 1 D on one of those cup winners and carried a pairing with Ron Hainsey during that.

the Devils were a couple of OT bounces away from winning a Cup with Mark Fayne on the #1 pairing

it isn't that big of a deal

 

[Gurglesons]

the Devils were a couple of OT bounces away from winning a Cup with Mark Fayne on the #1 pairing

it isn't that big of a deal

Lol. K bro. If you’re comparing Fayne and Dumo you’re not to be taken seriously.

Also, Kings went up 3-0 and the Devils won two games after it. “Couple bounces”. Then got blown out in Game 6. Lolol

 

[BHD]

Looks like fans - of both sides - ignored the "reasonable" part of the OP. Closed.