Proposal: Palmieri to Pittsburgh

[JTG]

the Devils are not trading Palmieri for nothing short of an overpay

I'm sorry this offends

Which is fine. Dumoulin is much more than an overpayment. And Palmieri will be booking the first ticket out of Newark when he can.

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

Which is fine. Dumoulin is much more than an overpayment. And Palmieri will be booking the first ticket out of Newark when he can.

Thank you for your concern.

like I said, you can't have Palms. Sorry if this offends.

 

[3074326]

these type of statements are always a weird "flex" to me. Just because another GM was a moron three years doesn't have ANYTHING to do with today.

I mean that just isn't true. Trades and contract value negotiations are clearly influenced by trades and contracts that have actually happened. And not just in the NHL. That's how the world works.....

 

[Billdo]

I mean that just isn't true. Trades and contract value negotiations are clearly influenced by trades and contracts that have actually happened. And not just in the NHL. That's how the world works.....

So because the Oilers GM was a fool and gave Hall away for Larsson, the Devils are somehow going to get a lesser deal than they ordinarily would because Hall was had for cheap? What kind of sense does that make?

 

[JTG]

Thank you for your concern.

like I said, you can't have Palms. Sorry if this offends.

The Pens wouldn't want Palmieri. They have 4 just like him.

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

The Pens wouldn't want Palmieri. They have 4 just like him.

Have a blessed day.

 

[Zajacs Bowl Cut]

nm

 

[Gurglesons]

So because the Oilers GM was a fool and gave Hall away for Larsson, the Devils are somehow going to get a lesser deal than they ordinarily would because Hall was had for cheap? What kind of sense does that make?

Dumoulin is a better defenseman than Larson and is on a cap controlled deal for the next four years.

Hall is a UFA. Does context mean nothing?

I’d be surprised if the return for Hall is anywhere close to a player like Dumo on that type of contract.

 

[JTG]

Have a blessed day.

Right now Rust, McCann, Guentzel, Kahun, and Hornqvist all have similar or better production. All except Hornqvist are younger.

 

[chethejet]

Dumo is a top D man with two cups. Pens are not trading him period. Plus, Pens can pick up a player at the TDL either a player for player or a team needing to move a UFA.

 

[Billdo]

Dumoulin is a better defenseman than Larson and is on a cap controlled deal for the next four years.

Hall is a UFA. Does context mean nothing?

I’d be surprised if the return for Hall is anywhere close to a player like Dumo on that type of contract.

none of that is the point of my post. My point was what the Devils paid for Hall 3 years ago has absolutely nothing to do with today.

 

[Gurglesons]

none of that is the point of my post. My point was what the Devils paid for Hall 3 years ago has absolutely nothing to do with today.

You’re right. They’d be lucky to get that kind of value.

 

[td_ice]

ah yeah we should just trade all our good players then

Like I said, the ask would be Dumoulin. That's fine if you don't think that's fair and don't want to pay it, but the Devils aren't going to trade him to the Pens otherwise.

I agree.

For the Devils to make a trade with a divisional rival, Dumo would be the ask. Pens of course would so no, but that is a reasonable, makes sense, ask.

 

[devils29]

Right now Rust, McCann, Guentzel, Kahun, and Hornqvist all have similar or better production. All except Hornqvist are younger.

Oh honey... oh no... this does not look good for you

 

[Unbiased Fan]

Probably not one for one, but a top pairing D who is basically on a sweet heart deal and has two cup rings playing top four minutes (including one as our de facto # 1) is certainly not going for a 50 pt wing who has never broken 20 ES goals.

Also, you got Hall for a worse version of Dumo.. So, weird flex.

He’s not a top pairing guy on a good defensive team.

 

[SomeDude]

He’s not a top pairing guy on a good defensive team.

He’s a top pairing guy on 2 Cup winning teams.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

He’s a top pairing guy on 2 Cup winning teams.

Yeah when Pittsburgh won it proved defence doesn’t win championships. The leafs defence is better then Pittsburgh’s when they won their last two cups.

 

[ChaosAgent]

He’s not a top pairing guy on a good defensive team.

Misnomer of a Username.

 

[Gurglesons]

He’s not a top pairing guy on a good defensive team.

Lol. Yes he is.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

Lol. Yes he is.

OEL is a decent top pairing guy not elite but decent. He has nothing on OEL. Toronto has the worst defence in the nhl and even Rielly/Barrie are better then him.

 

[Gurglesons]

OEL is a decent top pairing guy not elite but decent. He has nothing on OEL. Toronto has the worst defence in the nhl and even Rielly/Barrie are better then him.

Are you confusing top pairing D for # 1 D?

 

[Unbiased Fan]

Are you confusing top pairing D for # 1 D?

Well here is 31 LHD better then Dumolin so hopefully this proves my point.
Rielly, OEL, Hedman, Dahlin, Slavin, Makar, Werenski, Hieskanen, Ekholm, Hampus Lindholm, Girodano, Ryan Suter, Chabot, Provonov, Theodore, Morissey, Nurse, Klefbom, Hughes, Edler, Vlasic, Muzzin, McDonagh, Orlov, Schmidt, Krug, Kieth, Chara, Fowler, Lindel, Yandle

 

[Gurglesons]

Well here is 31 LHD better then Dumolin so hopefully this proves my point.
Rielly, OEL, Hedman, Dahlin, Slavin, Makar, Werenski, Hieskanen, Ekholm, Hampus Lindholm, Girodano, Ryan Suter, Chabot, Provonov, Theodore, Morissey, Nurse, Klefbom, Hughes, Edler, Vlasic, Muzzin, McDonagh, Orlov, Schmidt, Krug, Kieth, Chara, Fowler, Lindel, Yandle

Neat. Dumoulin would be a top pairing D on New Jersey if they traded for him. Dumoulin was a top pairing D on two cup winners. Glad you’ve listed a bunch of LDs.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

Neat. Dumoulin would be a top pairing D on New Jersey if they traded for him. Dumoulin was a top pairing D on two cup winners. Glad you’ve listed a bunch of LDs.

Tyler Smith is better lol

 

[chethejet]

Nice list, remind me how many cups do all those players have? Dumo is a top pairing D man with a really good AAV. Palmieri is a nice RW but something tells me he is gone one way or another. Pens can get him for far less at the TDL but Shero will ask to much and hope someone meets that ask. I assure you it will never be Dumo.