OMG and others
What would happen if we stood pat this year?
Trade maybe Bahl or Hoef and maybe Keating if we got the right offer.
Could this team be a contender next year?
Bit of a double edge sword there.
One of the reasons to not go for it is lack of punch from players like Tolnai and Robinson. If that is one of the prime reasons to sell, can those two be centre pieces next year? Probably not.
So, to answer your question, no, I don't think we'd be a contender next year. Too many variables need to line up...
1 - we'd need Rossi to return
2 - Andree would need to be a centrepiece to success
3 - both Robinson and Tolnai need to be major contributors
4 - Hoelscher needs to return as an OA
5 - the return for Bahl would need to include an impact 17 year old (2018 1st rounder)
I feel all of those things need to happen. If #2 and #3 are certain, they'd get that from them this year and it would put us into contender status right now.