I think regardless of who is right or wrong scouting wise I would hope that you can eventually look yourself in the mirror and realize that was a gratuitous,, unnecessary and self-serving post, given that's your main takeaway from a 9-1 game. This is a 20 year old kid who has been a spectacular junior player the whole year. Will he make a great pro? Frankly, who cares. He's the engine that drives this team's offence THIS year. Not sure where we'd be without him. You seem like a relatively smart guy but maybe rein yourself in a bit with Hoef. I think you've already made your opinion on him more than crystal clear.
I can understand your stance.
Certain players have holes in their game that go relatively unseen. That was an example of one of his weaknesses. It was a bad outlet pass. He isn't particularly great at that aspect of his game. It is another reason why his pro ability isn't there.
This isn't meant to be disrespectful. These players open themselves up for accolades as well as criicism. I feel as long as it stays based on their on ice abilities, assessments are fair game, whether they be positive or negative.
It would be different if I were to suggest he were a piece of crap hockey player and leave it at that.
I give specific examples of where his weaknesses lie. I also have balanced that with praise for his strengths.
There is no doubt Noel is a very successful OHL player. He, like thousands of other very successful OHL players, are not destined for successful pro careers because their games don't translate at the next level.
I've made my arguement as to why I feel that to be the case. That doesn't diminish the fact he has been very productive at the OHL level. It doesn't diminish the fact he seems, by all accounts, to be an exceptional teammate and good person.
In a 9-1 game, if we are to critique something, you would think it starts with the giveaway that led to the lone goal against, wouldn't you?