Ward Cornell
Registered User
- Dec 22, 2007
- 6,408
- 2,647
Don Cameron has said that the Mason trade was the worst in Ranger's history. (Don has been here since Day One, he'd know.) He said though, that it was the worst, not because of the trade itself, but because Mason's frequent NHL call ups and season ending injury limited him to only 16 regular season games (13-3 W-L) and 5 playoff games (5-0 W-L) as a Ranger.
I'm not a fan of what Spott the GM accomplished at trade deadline time over his 5 years in the position, but he did make some good moves at other times of the year when the pressure was off. One of those moves was the deal with London that brought Chris MacKinnon to the Rangers. All MacKinnon did was put up seasons of 81 and 90 points during the two years he was here. Add to that the 27 points in 20 games during the 2010 playoff run, and that's pretty damn good return for the two 3rd round picks sent to London in the deal.
I'd do that type of deal with London, or anyone else for that matter, every day of the week and twice on Sunday.
Never say never.
Hard to disagree with Don but I have to in this case.
IMHO the trade I truly dislike is the one the Sudbury trade last year. SS made that trade with all fingers crossed hoping that it would make the Rangers into a contender. There was absolutely nothing shown by the team last year that would suggest that they capable of being a champion. While that Mason trade the Rangers were by far the best team that year and Unice was the only 'weak link' on the team. Even giving up those assets to London, the Rangers still had a winning record against them when Kadri, Varone and Tarasuk were playing for them. Plus we also beat them in the playoffs a cpl years after.
Having Genovese, Schmaltz and Frankie this season for trading in the rebuild year would be mindblowing.
What do you think Guelph would give up just for Frankie????
Spott talked a good game but his coaching every year got worse and was more dependent on quality older players while he was busy getting his resume out to the pros.
Basically a 16 or 17 year old player needed to have exceptional talent to get any icetime under Spott the last few years of his tenure.
Last edited: