You just made my point for me: one of those "defensive first forwards" as you called them has matched Stammer's offensive production in the playoffs while being a far superior defensive player, is signed to barely half of what Stamkos is going to make, and yet we are likely to lose him precisely because we signed Stamkos to that ridiculous contract. I'm sorry but for $8.5M a player shouldn't produce in the games that matter most at the same rate as a "defensive first forward" or require high end talent feeding him the puck to be effective - he should be capable of taking over games on his own and elevating the play of his linemates rather than requiring them to elevate his.
So much wrong ... using things like "far superior defensive player" let me clue you in - its not 2009-2013 anymore. Using the contract of a player who has never scored above 41 points in a season as a comparable and not understanding the role that Stamkos plays on this team is really why I can't take you seriously man.
Your only argument ... and it seems the only one that can actually hold water is the "elevate the play of his linemates" line. Let me clue you in ... Yzerman specifically drafted Drouin to feed Stamkos pucks - its called the Yzerplan. We will pay Stamkos $8.5M to put pucks in the back of the net. How does Stamkos put pucks in the back of the net? by playing with a playmaker that can match his speed. I really could care less about his passing ability - we are not paying him $8.5M to be Crosby. We are paying him $8.5M to be himself, put pucks in the back of the net, and lead this franchise.
The only other player that is better than Stamkos at putting pucks in the net is Ovechkin and he has a $9.5M cap hit and that was signed like 10 years ago ... and compare his line mates to the ones Stamkos has been playing with. You are out in left field here and you keep pushing the same agenda non-stop. I usually just let it go 'cause its just a circular argument with you but I finally couldn't resist. And i'm not going to use your designated trademark emote as much as I'd like to.