After a bit more time playing...
Holy crap, Ones is fun and addicting. Went into World of Chel just thinking I'd mess around for a half hour or so last night and ended up going 3-4 hours (with some Three's and 3v3 EASHL worked in). All I want more than anything is to unlock some Sabres clothing/gear and represent.
Will definitely be participating in the full release, at least until I unlock enough to get my player decked out in Sabres stuff to my satisfaction.
Love the skating, very responsive. The game in general looks and feels great (for an NHL game, graphics aren't exactly mindblowing otherwise).
Beta is really glitchy. I have a feeling that the beta is probably an older build and a lot of these kinks are already ironed out... since we're only like a month and a half from release now and there's no way it releases with so many basic connectivity/loading issues. (Remember, go here to report your beta feedback:
NHL 19 Beta | Forum | EA Answers HQ | EN)
Poke checking penalties are starting to bug me. It's definitely hindering for more than just spamming. I felt bad with all the penalties I was getting playing defense in EASHL drop ins so I kept my finger off the button altogether. The one or two times I did poke check just out of habit/necessity, even when it seemed good positionally and the stick might've lightly grazed someones skate, I still got tripping penalties. Actually kinda forced me to play a little better and play the body more (yay improved hitting)... so I get it... but they probably could dial it back a little.
If the beta is anything to go by, this may very well be my favorite NHL release of the PS4/Xbox One generation. Hell, maybe my favorite of the last few generations. Probably end up pre-ordering it now instead of waiting for a deal and saving a few bucks.