On the other hand, it could turn into MLB 2k13, which is decent, but The Show absolutely blows it out of the water.
I still pop in ESPN NHL 2K5 occasionally
2k5 has remained my absolute favorite of all the NHL games. The ESPN-style presentation, good commentary from Thorne and Clement that was more varied than NHL 13's, great graphics for a $20 game, custom soundtracks, a deep franchise mode, and very tweakable game play that could be as arcade or as sim as you wanted. It's a shame the goalies weren't really great compared to 2k6 and that 2k5 had some franchise-breaking bugs.
EA's game has really stagnated and they're continuously focusing on the casual player, ignoring bug and AI fixes, and choosing to work on gimmicky features (we're improving hitting! Again!). But what really bums me is how many people will just eat it up all over again. Having the 2k franchise back in the game would be a breath of fresh air. But I highly doubt that's ever going to happen. They just don't have the money, the marketing, or the fans. And even when they did have the better game, the reviewers complained about complex controls and the customers hated the graphics.
EA *looks* realistic, but at its core, 2k had a game that *played* realistically. The problem was they didn't really commit to it with their default settings, they forced players to customize them to find the best game play. And the casual buyer isn't going to want to spend any time with sliders to make the game more realistic.