As the dust settles on this offseason, I have to be honest. I am deeply disappointed with the islanders' inaction. The team made great strides last season, but we have done little to nothing to capitalize on that success. Instead of making a big trade or signing any prominent free agents, we essentially just replaced Lehner with Varlamov and Filpula with Brassard. Meanwhile our rivals in the metropolitan have significantly improved - the rangers, flyers, hurricanes, and devils in particular.
I love Trotz, but I am, at this juncture, very skeptical of Lou as a GM. I question his methods, and in particular, I wonder whether he knows what it takes to win in the modern NHL.
Unfortunately based on our roster and our division, I expect the islanders to take a step back this season and miss the playoffs. Even worse, I expect them to be mediocre - not good enough to make the playoffs, but not bad enough for a top draft posistion, something which, for the most part, seems to be a necessary factor in order for a team to find eventual success (e.g. Pittsburgh, Chicago).
Mediocrity is a recipe for franchise purgatory. We have some good players, but only one star, and it is not enough in today's NHL to win with just a single cornerstone. We desperately need more young talented forwards, and unfortunately, it seems as though we are going to be trapped in the 10s to 20s posistion in the draft for the foreseeable future, and therefore, denied the chance to draft a talented franchise player. Meanwhile, more Kaako's and Hughes' are trickling into the NHL, playing for other teams.
I also hated our draft and, based on conversations with New Jersey fans, I dont think we will be having many good ones in the future. So although yes, players like Barzal occasionally drop to the mid teens, I dont anticipate us drafting consensus pick fallers... I expect us to draft more reaches like Holmstrom (who is, by the way, already injured).