Playoff team absolutely. I guess if you equate being in the playoffs as being a contender, you are right to a degree. A serious contender like they can get through Boston/Tampa or both, one of whom will have McD.....no.
no That is not how I judge a contender. I do it by asking myself does a team have certain things they as follows
a #1 C? check The Leafs have Matthews so they have a franchise C
If they do have a top line C do they have a supporting cast around him well...
Nylander, Marner, JVR, Marleau, Kadri, Brown Hyman they all have at least 10 goals and most of them either have hit 20, or should baring injury, so check.
if the team has #1 and 2 does it have a legitimate #1 goalie but #1 and 2 do not matter if you have no goalie.
Well while he is unlikely to win it, at this current pace Fredrik Andersen should get nominated for the Vezina so Check.
Does the team have a solid blue line?
this is where the weakness is, of that there is no question however, Reilly is playing like a #1 D manJake Gardiner and Nikita Zaitsev are both top 4 guys and Travis Dermott sure looks like a top 4 and when you lookm at the D core the pens won with the last 2 years, espically last year when they did it without Letang, you do want an improvement on the back end for sure but that Blue is not any worse than what the Pens won with, particularly last year so check.
Yes the Leafs are a contender, people refuse to accept it because the rebuild was so damn short, but it is time they accept the fact that Toronto has a chance to win the cup this year, although I would say it more likely next year.
But it is certainly possible this year.