Discussion in 'Trade Rumors and Free Agent Talk' started by Mark Kandy, Feb 14, 2020 at 11:21 AM.
What would it take to get both Dumba and Brodin to the Habs?
Domi + ??
Yeah. Like I said, I see that deal happening in June given Bergevin past record. My prediction is it gets done on June 15th, feel free to quote me on that in the future.
I think it’s a good basis. I do think Dumba is more valuable, but I’d probably end up doing it 1 for 1 just due to need
Domi + 2020 1st
Minny won't trade both.
Value wise, it would be 2 Domis.
Man, that 2020 1st is very valuable to Montreal. This is still a good value deal, I'd do that for sure without even thinking twice if I was Bergevin (after the lottery, of course).
I tend to think the same, but with Domi being more valuable.
Dumba is not the same player he were before the injuries. The only way for him is down.
As a Montreal fan I don't want Dumba near my roster, and as a Minnesota fan I want him moved for a top 6 forward.
I think they're close, but I also think Dumba is worth a bit more. 1 for 1 would not be outrageous.
Would Minny do Domi + Poehling + Chiarot for Dumba + Brodin?
Funny how you’re always more inclined to think your player is more valuable. I just say Dumba because I know what he was last year and know there’s a chance that he can be that again. It was incredible to watch. He was so dynamic from the blue line. Looked like he was going to be a 1D for the next decade for us. That’s why I have trouble with the idea of trading him after a bad half of a season. He’s been much better since the all-star break. For me, I think Domi and Dumba are both having bad years, but I Valued Dumba >>>> Domi coming I to this year.
His game has really started to take off again these last few weeks. And you're kidding yourself if you think Wild fans want him moved for a top 6 forward. We don't want him moved PERIOD. But if we did, it would be for a player like Domi.
Not a chance
Then I would trade Petry for a 1st+ and trade that 1st I got from Petry + Domi for Dumba + Brodin.
Mtl would not
Still not a chance. Domi + late 1st isn’t going to cut it. I’m not even sure that Montreal’s 1st would, I just think that it would be OK on value
Damn dude I haven’t read anything this dumb all week. Nice work.
so we can have a core RD to follow our core age curve.
And to also cash-in at his highest value on Petry
Lol, MTL's 1st is almost guaranteed to be a top-10 pick (especially with Weber gone for a while) and/or maybe even top 3 if we make the lottery. No way in hell Brodin is worth top-3 or even a top-10 pick at this year's draft (I'd rather go for one of Anaheim's LHD at that price)... Maybe Domi + mid-late 1st (from Petry) + a good prospect (not top prospect).
I’d say Brodin probably has the worth of a pick around 15, give or take based on team need. Dumba + Brodin would be worth a ton. Maybe even more, depending on how you view Dumba.
It's honestly one of the best plan you can think of.
Dumba fits well, similar play-style to Petry so we can move on to Petry with a prospect + 2020 first.
Domi fits well Minnesota and fill in 2c while Stall is still there and playing well.
all in all it seems like a really good fit for both and it helps both team. BUT our GM has seriously no ****ing vision so I highly doubt he will trade Domi, Petry or Tatar.
I agree that Brodin is worth a mid-1st pick. But the thing is this draft is pretty strong and MTL is getting a top-10 pick (maybe even top-3). I wouldn't trust MTL's future at all either (1st 2021, etc).
But yeah, my offer would be Domi + mid-late 1st (from Petry trade) + good (B) prospect.
Look, We need a RD that will lead after Weber. Dumba will be around 27-28. We still need "young veteran" in 2+ years and Dumba would be that.
You don't win without a Vet #1RD except if you are Makar
Yeah the pick would have to have top 3 protection. I just see Dumba > Domi (slightly) so I think value-wise Montreal’s 1st would make the deal OK for me assuming they picked ~10th. It’s a good draft, but we’d literally be Detroit bad if we made that trade, so...
I don't care what the ''consenus'' in the Wild fanbase is. I want him out.
Separate names with a comma.