Proposal: McDonagh to Jets..?

[StatisticsAddict99]

Proposal:

Is it fair and would it benefit both sides?

Click to read more...

 

[Filthy Dangles]

delete

 

[Brock Radunske]

View attachment 95897

Proposal:

McDonagh for Vesalainen, Niku, Copp and a 1st and 3rd Round Pick...

Is it fair and would it benefit both sides?

Props on the flair!

 

[KirkAlbuquerque]

ooo pretty

 

[rent free]

Rangers fans who know nothing about the prospects offered will say it's a bad deal.

 

[Evil Little]

I just don't see the Jets as being in the market for a top 4 D, let alone a #1D.

I think the value looks a little hefty, though. Best forward prospect and best D prospect? (Obviously, McDonagh is going to cost someone a fortune, so it's really not that bad...)

 

[migi]

Not bad. I think Rangers should target Roslovic though and maybe take Vesalainen and 3rd off.

Roslovic, Niku, 1st & Copp for McDonagh.

 

[EpicDing]

Good value I think. Not sure if it's something Winnipeg needs to do though.

 

[Alluckks]

Rangers fans who know nothing about the prospects offered will say it's a bad deal.

You are one annoyed boy in every Rangers thread, it is hilarious

 

[tgo0]

It’s a steep price to pay but that’s probably the return McD will get, not sure I want to do that from a Jets POV though.

In the offseason if it’s apparent Trouba isn’t resigning then I’d probably be a lot more open to something like this. Or maybe something like Trouba instead of Vesalainen and the 1st.

 

[Kupo]

Rangers fans who know nothing about the prospects offered will say it's a bad deal.

Why do you hate the Rangers so much ?

 

[Lays]

The value is perfect but if Vesalainen were a RHS winger or a dman I'd do it

Yes I know who Vesalainen and Niku are, impressive prospects especially the former

 

[Maukkis]

We should not trade Niku. Our D prospect pipeline is bad enough as it is; trading Niku would further destroy our hopes of replacing older defensemen for cheap. I can live with giving up a first and even Vesalainen (that one stings, though) for McDonagh, but after those two, any more substantial pieces won't be added.

 

[rent free]

Why do you hate the Rangers so much ?

I don't hate the rangers. I just hate when teams have a high value player and want the moon for them. I wish for them to get half of what they request and would want to see their reactions after

 

[Shootertooter]

It’s a steep price to pay but that’s probably the return McD will get, not sure I want to do that from a Jets POV though.

In the offseason if it’s apparent Trouba isn’t resigning then I’d probably be a lot more open to something like this. Or maybe something like Trouba instead of Vesalainen and the 1st.

If the Rangers could talk to Trouba about resigning ahead of a trade with Wpg.
I would make the trade from the Rangers perspective.

 

[Kaapo di tutti capi]

I don't hate the rangers. I just hate when teams have a high value player and want the moon for them. I wish for them to get half of what they request and would want to see their reactions after

That's pretty much fans of every team on HF.

 

[Shootertooter]

I don't hate the rangers. I just hate when teams have a high value player and want the moon for them. I wish for them to get half of what they request and would want to see their reactions after

That applies to pretty much every proposal on this forum.

 

[rent free]

You are one annoyed boy in every Rangers thread, it is hilarious

Hilarious you say that because it's just a coincidence that there are rangers threads at the front page.

 

[rent free]

Yup and that's

That applies to pretty much every proposal on this forum.

why I love it so much when it happens.

 

[DRW204]

jets having this D next year with Enstroms contract ending would be lethal

Morrissey-Trouba
McDonagh-Buff
Kulikov-Myers

 

[GaryPoppins]

No way Wpg does this. Like, at all.

 

[Pongs21]

Is Nash or Zuc included? If not too rich for me

 

[rent free]

That's pretty much fans of every team on HF.

What about the second part? Are fans like that too?

 

[Whileee]

No way Wpg does this. Like, at all.

Agree. Jets' future success will depend on keeping a pipeline of good young players so they can manage the cap with their core. McDonagh offers them just a year and a half before UFA, and Chevy has said often that the Jets' strategy is to build for long-term success, which means sticking with a draft and develop philosophy.

 

[StatisticsAddict99]

We should not trade Niku. Our D prospect pipeline is bad enough as it is; trading Niku would further destroy our hopes of replacing older defensemen for cheap. I can live with giving up a first and even Vesalainen (that one stings, though) for McDonagh, but after those two, any more substantial pieces won't be added.

We still have Stanley and Samberg, plus Kulikov is looking pretty good this season and he’s not old either, so we should have many LD options in the future.