Max Domi v William Nylander

[Mrb1p]

While I didn't vote for the Tkachuk one, as I'd take Tkachuck ahead of Domi right now, but well see at the end of the year, this one is Domi by a small, but fair margin, IMO.

 

[Ainec]

I'd go with Nylander

Domi is a better fit on the habs or even the leafs

 

[Green Snow Storm]

No i'm taking the player that is leading his team instead of the one that is just a passenger.

Different situations. It would be the same thing if the players switched teams. Nylander would play Center in Montreal and their offence would run through him, while Domi would be playing on Matthews or Tavares wing in Toronto.

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

Different situations. It would be the same thing if the players switched teams. Nylander would play Center in Montreal and their offence would run through him, while Domi would be playing on Matthews or Tavares’ wing in a Toronto.

Drouin and Galchenyuk both played center in Montreal and it didn't work... Chances are Nylander at center would not work

 

[Green Snow Storm]

Drouin and Galchenyuk both played center in Montreal and it didn't work... Chances are Nylander at center would not work

No disrespect to either as they’re both good players, but I think Nylander is better than both. It’s impossible to say how well he would react to being a full time centre until it’s tried and it won’t be in Toronto.

 

[nickdawg95]

Domi cause he's actually playing on a NHL team atm

 

[sharks9]

Domi just keeps producing, I know Nylander is a year younger but Domi will likely break Nylander's career-highs this year

 

[Atomos2]

Nylander. I don't blame Hab fans for getting their licks in when Nylander isn't playing though.

 

[MattMartin]

Woof, this is bad.

 

[ottawa]

Nylander. I don't blame Hab fans for getting their licks in when Nylander isn't playing though.

Can we get them in now?

 

[sharks9]

On pace for 70 points vs. on pace for 30

 

[Atomos2]

Can we get them in now?

If you'd like. I still take Nylander in the future pretty easily though

 

[ottawa]

If you'd like. I still take Nylander in the future pretty easily though

Location: Toronto, Ontario

 

[Atomos2]

Location: Toronto, Ontario

I wonder if my location changes when we compare every other player in Toronto

 

[WillTheThrill]

Still Nylander